Bitcoin 'creator' U-turns on promise to prove his story
Craig Wright apologises to figures who backed his claim to have invented the digital currency
An Australian who said he was the inventor of digital currency Bitcoin has made an abrupt U-turn on his promise to prove his claim.
Craig Wright approached the BBC and other media outlets on Monday to say he was "Satoshi Nakamoto", the pseudonym used by the mysterious Bitcoin creator.
When questioned further, the businessman promised to provide incontrovertible proof to counter sceptics.
However, he has now deleted the blog in which he outlined his claim and replaced it with a single post, headlined: "I'm Sorry."
"I believed that I could do this. I believed that I could put the years of anonymity and hiding behind me," he writes.
"But, as the events of this week unfolded and I prepared to publish the proof of access to the earliest keys, I broke. I do not have the courage. I cannot."
Rory Cellan-Jones, the technology correspondent for the BBC, says he was convinced Wright's claim was true not so much because of the proof he offered, but because he was backed by two senior figures in the Bitcoin Foundation, Jon Matonis and Gavin Andresen.
Andresen said Wright had privately shown him undeniable proof and later wrote: "I am very happy to be able to say I shook his hand and thanked him for giving Bitcoin to the world." He now says he was mistaken.
Matonis, however, yesterday implied he still has faith, writing on Twitter that while Wright will not now offer his proof of identity, there "won't be another Satoshi".
There won't be an on-chain signing from early bitcoin blocks, but there also won't be another Satoshi.
— Jon Matonis (@jonmatonis) May 5, 2016
Wright refers to the two men in his apology, saying: "I can only hope that their honour and credibility is not irreparably tainted by my actions. They were not deceived, but I know that the world will never believe that now."
Cellan-Jones says only that the U-turn is "bound to create fresh doubts". The journalist does not say he no longer believes Wright, but could be forgiven for washing his hands of the businessman, given the damage to his own professional reputation.
There's no doubt that Wright's climb-down does "provide ammunition to those who speculated his claims were not true", says Wired.
UK tech magazine The Register remains entirely convinced Wright is not Nakamoto. Dubbing him "Yeah Wright" and "the creator of Craig Wright", not Bitcoin, it suggests the Australian is just seeking the "oxygen of publicity".
His claim is "transparently false", adds the site: "Craig Wright is not Satoshi Nakamoto. Why he wants people to believe he is, well, that's something for him and his therapist to figure out."
What is a Bitcoin?
A full explanation of Bitcoin and how it works "would take several thousand words", says the Daily Telegraph, but a more concise description is that it is a "currency that only exists in cyberspace, with holders storing their stash in a virtual 'wallet' and making transfers over the internet". ABC News offers an even briefer description: "If hard currency is like a record, then Bitcoin is like an MP3."
Bitcoin: Coinbase in talks to open first UK exchange
Online currency Bitcoin is set to take another step into the mainstream as it was revealed that one of the world’s biggest digital currency markets, Coinbase, is in talks with UK financial regulators about setting up a Bitcoin exchange in the UK.
Coinbase opened the first regulated Bitcoin exchange in the United States this year, after receiving $106 million in backing from the New York stock exchange, The Times reported.
Now Brian Armstrong, CEO of Coinbase, hopes to set up in the UK as well.
In an interview with The Times, Armstrong said he had been in conversation with UK regulators for six months and that discussions were "positive and all moving in the right direction", but added that he was "hesitant to avoid putting any measure" on a potential launch date.
Coinbase is a company "entirely focused" on making it easier for businesses and individuals to buy and sell Bitcoins, Medium said.
The company also intends to help Bitcoin shake off its image as the currency of choice for drug dealers and criminals on the so-called "dark web".
Armstrong is hopeful that with increased regulation, the currency will become more stable. The price of one Bitcoin is currently hovering around $250, having crashed from highs of more than $1,200 at the end of 2013.
"[Bitcoin] is getting less volatile every year and I think that trend will continue,” Armstrong said. “There was a bubble period and the end of 2013 and the beginning of 2014. We saw this massive run-up in the price that didn't match the actual price of Bitcoin underneath."
Juniper Research suggests the value of all crypto-currencies is likely to drop by more than half this year, from $71 billion to $30 billion, The Times noted. But Coinbase stressed that, for the time being, it does not intend to deal in any currency other than Bitcoin.
"Our mission is to enable consumers from around the world to access a cheap, fast, global payment network. It's pretty clear right now that Bitcoin is the dominant payment network, and we feel that adding another digital currency would slow us down in our mission by confusing people who are just being introduced to the concept of digital currencies."
How much is a Bitcoin worth?
In 2011, one Bitcoin unit was priced at $1. Today it is worth $305. While this seems like a massive increase, Bitcoin's price has actually been falling since its peak of $1,147 in December 2013, with its drop in value partly blamed on a clampdown on the currency by Chinese authorities.
Who invented Bitcoin?
The identity of the mastermind behind Bitcoin has been shrouded in secrecy. The concept entered the public domain in 2008 and was credited to a "pseudonymous developer" known as Satoshi Nakamoto. It has been suggested – by Ted Nelson, one of the web's founding fathers – that Nakamoto is the Japanese mathematician Shinichi Mochizuki. That claim has not been verified, but you can read a detailed explanation of Nelson's argument here.
In March, Newsweek claimed the founder was Dorian Prentice Satoshi Nakamoto, a 64-year-old father-of-six living near Los Angeles – although a brief interview with Nakamoto himself offered no concrete evidence that it was him.
Where do you get Bitcoins?
The world's first Bitcoin ATM opened in Vancouver on 1 November 2013. The machine allows "users to exchange their credits of the digital currency for cash and vice-versa", says the BBC. In May last year, a new bank called Circle also opened its virtual doors to users of the currency. The Boston-based financial services company allows users to deposit currency and see it converted instantly to Bitcoin without any fees. Users are then able to use their account to make transactions. Circle says that it aims to make Bitcoin easier to use for real-world purchases; at present, the cryptocurrency tends to be used primarily as an investment.
If you don't want to trade hard cash for Bitcoins, you can also "mine" new ones.
How do you mine Bitcoins?
You won't need a shovel. Bitcoins are "hidden amid a complex encrypted computer program", explains ABC News. Users have their computers "working round the clock to solve a complicated mathematical problem in order to release new coins". Of the 21 million possible Bitcoins, about 11 million have already been unearthed. You can also mine coins using your smartphone, says Know Your Mobile – but don't expect quick returns. Eight hours of running a Bitcoin-mining app, unearthed just 0.0005 coins. That's because finding new coins requires enormous amounts of computing power which has led some hackers to take over unsuspecting users' machines to harness more power.
The Bitcoin system is designed so that the work required to find new Bitcoins rises steadily as each coin is uncovered. "That makes the currency's growth rate, also known as inflation, steady and predictable," says ABC News.
How do you spend Bitcoins?
If you want to buy something using Bitcoins you need to make sure the seller accepts the cryptocurrency. If they do, you acquire the anonymous identification number attached to the seller's "wallet" then move coins from your virtual wallet to theirs. The "anonymity" of these transactions has made the currency particularly popular with drug dealers, says ABC News.
Will Bitcoin replace existing currencies?
That's the big question. the Telegraph suggests Bitcoin does present a serious challenge, saying: "Unless the issues that Bitcoin raises are addressed in a thoughtful and proactive manner by existing authorities, the disintermediating power of technology is likely to have a disruptive impact on currency systems and those that regulate and rely on them".
Simon Johnson, a professor of entrepreneurship at MIT's Sloan School of Management, told Mashable that a Bitcoin "backlash" is likely as "governments and established financial institutions" fight to retain their supremacy. Bitcoin will "face political pressure and aggressive lobbying from big banks because of its disruptive nature," says Johnson.
Bitcoin: is Circle the world's first crypto-currency bank?
BITCOIN took a tentative step towards the mainstream today as a new bank called Circle opened its virtual doors to users of the currency, but analysts say it may have a hard time attracting users.
The Boston-based financial services company will allow users to deposit currency and see it converted instantly to Bitcoin without any fees. Users will then be able to use their account to make transactions. Circle says that it aims to make Bitcoin easier to use for real-world purchases; at present, the cryptocurrency tends to be used primarily as an investment.
"The focus is on making this easier for people to adopt," says the company's CEO, Jeremy Allaire.
"There have been a lot of barriers and friction and complexity to digital money formats over the past year or so. What we've tried to do with the service is remove a great deal of the complexity."
According to TheNextWeb's Josh Ong, Circle is hoping to do for virtual currency what Skype did for video phone calls. "Circle is utilising the benefits of Bitcoin – instant, secure, global and free – to help customers store money and make payments", Ong says.
To use the service, customers will need to link their bank account, credit card or debit card and add money into their Circle account. They can then make transactions using Circle in any currency without conversion fees. In an effort to assuage people's concerns about storing their money in a virtual currency, Circle displays finances in US dollars rather than Bitcoin.
Still, The Verge's Casey Newton says that Circle may have a hard time convincing people to use the service, because "it remains unclear why the average person would conduct a transaction in Bitcoin instead of cash". But, he says, in the long run there may be some advantages: "Advocates for the cryptocurrency say that merchants may eventually offer discounts to Bitcoin users that take advantage of lower transaction fees".
Yet in spite of the fact that the service offers no immediate advantages, Circle already a sizable waiting list of people hoping to sign up.
The service has raised $26m from investors and has a credible collection of financiers on its board of directors. Its future remains far from clear, but as Newton says, the technology and the philosophy behind it seem inevitable. "Whether it is Circle, or another startup that comes along, we're on the verge of free, instant access to our funds from any device and anywhere in the world".