Scotland can issue 'Braveheart bonds' but they will cost more

George Osborne

Osborne gives Scotland more fiscal powers in 'historic moment' but SNP insists it is 'nothing new'

LAST UPDATED AT 12:54 ON Wed 19 Feb 2014

THE Treasury has given Scotland permission to issue up to £2.2bn on the international bond markets, but has warned that it is "unlikely to be a cost effective form of borrowing".

The move will give the Holyrood administration an extra source of financing when it gets new borrowing powers in 2015. However, Westminster will not guarantee the so-called "Braveheart bonds" and Scotland will not be able to borrow at the UK's low borrowing rate.

The possibility of the bonds, which can be issued for capital investment in roads, hospitals, schools and flood defences, was first set out as an amendment to the Scotland Bill in June 2011, which was passed as the Scotland Act in 2012.

Following a consultation, the Treasury said today that there would be no risk from Scottish bonds to the rest of the UK. However, it added that the cost of issuing such bonds would be "significantly above the UK's cost of borrowing" because of the "market's view of the Scottish government as a worse credit risk than the UK as a whole".

The announcement comes a year earlier than expected, and seven months ahead of the 18 September independence referendum, which will see voters in Scotland asked the Yes/No question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

George Osborne described today's decision as "an historic moment for Scotland" and claimed it was further evidence of why being part of the UK "gives Scotland the best of both worlds".

However, the Scottish government said it was "nothing new", arguing that Scotland's total borrowing limit will still be £2.2bn, and only independence would give Scotland full control of its finances.

"Government bond issuance is normally a technical financial instrument for the secure handling of the public finances," says the BBC's Douglas Fraser. "But in Scotland in 2014, it's raw politics."

The UK government wants to send the signal that it is handing over more powers to Scotland without the need for full independence, he says, but the Scottish government's response is that the move is too constrained, and comes too late. · 

Disqus - noscript

'Braveheart Bonds'. Honestly, who comes up with these names. Rhetoric journalism once again from a media that will be partly to blame for pushing Scotland to Independence.

Every time that fake chancellor Osborne opens his mouth he insults someone. What can you expect from a Tory buffoon with a Degree in MODERN HISTORY! Shut your mouth Osborne and go and get yourself a proper qualification so you can deserve to keep the job you can't do and shouldn't have. Other people that are not from rich families need to have proper qualifications to get or keep the job they want!

For further concise, balanced comment and analysis on the week's news, try The Week magazine. Subscribe today and get 6 issues completely free.