India unimpressed by Oz and Kiwi racist jokes
Australia and New Zealand’s relations with India are coming under strain thanks to some crass attempts at humour
Australia and New Zealand have a reputation as welcoming countries - as the thousands of Britons who migrate Down Under each year could attest. But the countries' relationship with another source of skilled migrants - India - is becoming less friendly by the day.
Accusations of racism towards Indians have recently been thrown around in Australia and New Zealand even while their athletes compete in the Commonwealth Games in Delhi.
Only this week in Australia, details emerged of an email that has been circulated among police in the state of Victoria. It contained footage of an Indian man on top of a train being electrocuted by overhead wires and was accompanied by a comment suggesting it could be a way to "fix" the Indian student "problem". As many as 15 officers face disciplinary charges related to the email.
The affair has reopened a row that last boiled over in January after a string of attacks on Indians across Australia culminated in the killing of Nitin Garg, a 21-year-old accountancy student, in Melbourne, the state capital of Victoria.
The Indian media were outraged by the treatment of their citizens Down Under and decried Australia as a racist country that refused to protect Indians who had moved there to further themselves. Australia's reaction to India's coverage, which included a cartoon depicting an Australian police officer as a member of the Ku Klux Klan, was typically blunt.
Members of the Australian government attacked the Indian media and the secretary of Victoria's Police Association, Greg Davies, observed: "Cartoons in Australia are normally done by people who are either clever or witty and this one's neither."
Tensions continue to simmer in Melbourne and as the Sydney Morning Herald reported earlier in the year: "Being Indian in Melbourne in 2010 is not the most comfortable of situations."
Over in New Zealand, well-known TV host Paul Henry was forced to resign at the weekend after an interview with prime minister John Key, in which he questioned whether Governor-General Sir Anand Satyanand, who is of Indian-Fijian heritage, could really be a Kiwi.
He asked whether Sir Anand was "even a New Zealander" and urged an uncomfortable-looking Key to ensure that his successor would "look and sound like a New Zealander".
Perhaps worse was Henry's mocking of Delhi chief minister Sheila Dikshit, which also sparked a diplomatic incident. During a feature about preparations for the Commonwealth
Games he deliberately mispronounced the name. Despite being told it was pronounced Dix-it, he giggled away for over a minute - at one point calling her dip-shit - as his mortified co-presenters shuffled awkwardly.
Another high-profile media figure in New Zealand, radio presenter Michael Laws has also apologised after he waded into the row over Henry's comments about Sir Anand. He made matters worse when he told his listeners: "[Sir Anand] is a very large, fat man. I don't know why but just on an Indian it seems slightly incongruous.
"I mean, we don't all expect Indians to be begging on the streets of New Delhi, but it's like Anand discovered the buffet table at, like, 20 and he's never really left it."
He had earlier refused to apologise, saying: "I didn't realise weight was a racial issue," he said. "I just said he's a fat Indian man, which is true. He's a fat Indian."
The issue of racism Down Under is not a new one and has even caught the eye of Bollywood film makers. A movie about race relations between Indians and Australians hit the cinemas last week. The film called Crook - It's Good To Be Bad is billed as "an unflinching look at the burning issue of racism which has devastated the lives of thousands of young Indians, who went to Australia in search of a better life".
Coincidentally the main character in Crook is called Jai Dixit - an alternative spelling of Dikshit. ·
Comments are now closed on this article















Comments
Racism happening anywhere is to be condemned, but this is clearly a case of the pot calling the kettle black! When AIDS was at its zenith, the Indian government insisted that ALL Africans, including diplomatic personnel going to India, should be tested for HIV and denied entry if found positive. Although at the time AIDS was more rampant in the USA than anywhere else, no such restrictions or conditions were placed on Americans. And this is only one of the very many examples of racism practised by Indians on an official level. Not to mention how their own darker skinned Dalits are treated, what?
Whilst in NZ I took tea at an establishment on the North Island called 'Golliwogs.' There were Gollies of all sizes as part of the ambience there. [I also have three at home, my wife is Indian and sees nothing wrong with them]. I remember that as I climbed into the ute outside the radio presenter stated the Pope had commented that he found New Zealanders the most irreverant race on earth. Thought that was well funny, especially as I couldn't make my mate or the proprietor of the restaurant understand why we'd never have a caf�© of that style in the UK
A somewhat hypocritical article. The pictures of Ms Dikshit with a foul looking incomplete toilet in the background was prominent in the FP reporting on the CG preparation delays with unnecessary repetition of the ladies name giving a clue to the immature sniggering in the FP press room. Oh how they must have been enjoying themselves.
You said 15 were being investigated over this email. That is incorrect. 15 (and perhaps more now) were/are being investigated for a number of different emails, including porn (probably legal). 2 were being investigated in regards to this Indian email. 1 has resigned. The other may not have made any comments about Indians or India for all we know. This officer distributed a link to a shock video, one which has been seen by millions of people. The one who did comment was, evidently, being very sarcastic. From what has been reported, I can't see how it is being portrayed as a haha joke. Given the Indian press labeled them KKK, it doesn't surprise me 1 officer in 11,000 would make a controversial private statement that probably should have stayed private! Furthermore, Nitin Garg was a murder, one of many in this country. He wasn't killed because he was Indian. The police have the motive but can't reveal because the guilty party is 15 and it potentially violates aging laws because the motive will probably lead to his identification. They say racism was not part of the motive.