The big crash – America plunges into Depression

Alexander Cockburn: Young Americans have given up watching the news. It’s too depressing

Column LAST UPDATED AT 16:31 ON Thu 8 Jul 2010
Alexander Cockburn

It's the worst of times. America is plunging back into Depression. Only one out of every two Americans of working age has a job. Forty years ago that would have been okay. Dad went to the factory. Mom stayed at home to mind the kids. These days, just  to keep the show on the road, mom and pop both work and the kids go to daycare. 

Start looking for work now and on average it will take till next April for you to find something. Across the last two months, more than a million Americans simply gave up seeking employment, even as benefits are running out. Ironically, if you quit looking for work you count as officially "discouraged", and don't figure in the official unemployment stats, which is the only reason that number hasn't shot up  to record highs.

Somewhere near 10 million Americans without work aren't getting any kind of cheque. One in every five children is living below the poverty line, sometimes by as much as 50 per cent – classed as "extreme poverty". Across America, in state after state the till is empty. Barack Obama's home state of Illinois is effectively bankrupt. So is California. Forty-six of the 50 states are buried under huge deficits.

The stimulus has failed. The housing market is in free fall. A couple of months ago market analysts predicted there will be five million more foreclosures between now and 2011 and it looks like they're on target. Forty per cent of delinquent homeowners have already loaded up the SUV, thrown the plastic chairs in the swimming pool and tossed the house keys back at the bank. Worse still, only 30 per cent of foreclosures have been re-listed for sale. The banks have been keeping them back to avoid flooding the market.

For tens of millions of Americans the house is as central and crucial a financial asset as a pig was for an Irish peasant family in the 19th century. The pig, as the old Irish saying went, was "the man beside the fire". It had the place of honour. The pig died, the family starved. Knock 20 per cent off the aggregate value of housing in America today and that means sunset years of penny pinching and, of course, yet one more knife in the belly for the overall economy.

And yet... if not the best of times, you can hardly say that America is broke. It's not. As the economic columnist Carl Ginsburg remarks, "America is awash in cash. This is a very, very rich country with piles and piles of cash. Private US accounts today contain approximately $10 trillion in cash and liquid assets.  

"On the corporate side, non-financial US corporations are holding more than $1.8 trillion, constituting a 26 per cent increase as of March from one year earlier - the largest increase on record going back to 1952."

The problem is that the banks don't want to put money out, because they think ordinary Americans are too broke to pay it back. Ordinary Americans agree. They've carried America forward through the past decade on the backs of their credit cards and they can't totter another step. They're out of juice.

In the measured argot of the IMF, "Financial crises typically follow periods of rapid expansion in lending and strong increases in asset prices. Recoveries from these recessions are often held back by weak private demand and credit reflecting, in part, households' attempts to increase saving rates to restore balance sheets. Globally synchronised recessions are longer and deeper than others."

(Political footnote to the foregoing: the recession of 1980 finished off President Jimmy Carter: the recession of 1992 did for George Bush Sr and put Bill Clinton into the White House.)

Of course America is wildly rich. How else could it find room in its heart for the legal tax write-offs that allow Americans to deduct contributions to Israelis establishing illegal settlements on the West Bank? How could it pay the $2 million in direct and indirect bribes to the Taliban a week - or is it a day? - in Afghanistan to allow its supply convoys down roads so that the counter-insurgency against the Taliban can continue, if not prosper?
 
Counter-insurgency means drones that kill civilians and do the Taliban no end of good. But drones mean jobs in jobless America. The Wisconsin National Guard is planning to build a new $8m base for unmanned drones. Whiteman Air Force Base in Missouri is to be a drone base control. In South Dakota, Rapid City's nearby Ellsworth Force Base also recently won a drone contract.

In none of these places was there much of anything but joy at the news. "There was great news for Ellsworth Force Base and for the Rapid City community," declared the local Black Hills Fox Channel. Missouri Congressman Ike Skelton said he'd worked for a year to win the Predator. The Rapid City Journal editorial page was ecstatic: "Ellsworth and its many supporters have done Rapid City and South Dakota proud."
 
It's the best of times for Republicans who have scant sympathy for out-of-work people anyway and who have every political incentive to ensure that by mid-term election day, November 2, they'll be able to hang America's latest "worst of times" around the necks of Obama and the Democrats.
 
Dean Baker, who co-directs the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington DC, explains the Republicans' heartless maths: "State and local governments have cut their workforce by an average of 65,000 a month over the last three months [as they have to do, because they are legally bound to balance their budgets]. Without substantial aid from the federal government this pace is likely to accelerate. The Republican agenda in blocking aid to the states may add another 300,000 people to the unemployment roles by early November."

The Republicans'  blockage of extended unemployment benefits promises similar dividends. Unemployment benefits are not just about providing income support to those who are out of work, they also provide a boost to the economy, which is why the Republicans have been especially keen to cut them off.

It's the worst of times. People are down. I meet young people every day who say they've simply given up watching the news. It's all too depressing.

The Washington Post ran a story on July 6 by Kimberly Kindy that established that "in the 77 days since oil from the ruptured Deepwater Horizon began to gush into the Gulf of Mexico, BP has skimmed or burned about 60 per cent of the amount it promised regulators it could remove in a single day."

As of Monday July 5, with about two million barrels released into the gulf, the skimming operations that were touted as key to preventing environmental disaster have averaged less than 900 barrels a day.

As William Empson wrote in his poem Missing Dates:

Slowly the poison the whole blood stream fills…The waste remains, the waste remains and kills.

Who can feel it's anything other than the worst of times when the Gulf of Mexico is set to die before our eyes. · 

Comments

As history tells us when the state of the economy deteriorates the empire goes to war for if not how come there is such a huge army and navy and who is the enemy

I am an American 51 years old. Conservative put two kids through college and live the American dream. I have owned airplanes yachts and boats. Have a great wife and Grandchildren.
I welcome a depression or deep recession. It will make us even stronger. You in the UK think we will be weak, no we will be strong. You think all we care about is possessions, no we care about each other. We can be happy with or without and that my friends is what a real American is all about. If I loose my yacht I will be ok.. even if I never own one again.. We are not slaves, we like to work and be free to succeed or fail. I would rather have freedom to fail than to have never tried to succeed.
I hate socialism and lazy people that are like little pigs sucking on nipples of the govt. asking for handouts. Life Liberty and the pursuit of happiness is what makes America great.
We have propped up the rest of the world, if we fall other countries will have it worse and we will come back first. After all we are Americans and proud.
So hear is hoping for the fall, I will proudly crawl out of the hole with the rest of my great Americans.
After a fall, prices stabilize and we start making all our products in America again the rest of the world will be in serious trouble.. better hope we dont fall...that would be the end of many countries.
I love America, I am an American, too bad not all people have not been able to live my dream.. If I die today I can say I have worked hard and loved my family.. I am a truly blessed and proud American.

I have to say this is a study in depression.
It would be amusing I am sure, for a homeless Hatian to consider the suffering of an American " loading up the SUV and throwing the chairs into the pool ".
However - the danger to the rest of the world if the US economy does not recover is real enough - God knows what a really serious downturn might trigger - like the 1930s?
Obama and his crew are trying to steer the jalopy away from the cliff - it is pathetic to hear the cacophony of complaints from all sides. As if the whole country had just woken up to find that someone has stolen the credit card.
It is disingenuous to lay the blame on the usual suspects of big business et al. My understanding of the root causes of the whole mess, is that it was set in motion when the democrats under Clinton decided to interfere in the housing market, forcing the system to give loans to people who could not afford it, thus creating the ocean of bad debt in the first place.
And who was buying all those homes?
There was a funny sketch on SNL about the poor triple home-owners whose dreams of riches were dashed by the housing crisis. It was not very popular - I wonder why?

Oh, and no more Bankster BAILOUTS!!!!! There is over $1 Quadrillion ($1,000+ Trillion or $1,000,000+ Billion) in toxic, fraudulent, derivatives that can never be paid off. These international banks need to die (go bankrupt): die and go to hell!

This is most definitely a depression, with no end...unless Americans wake up and demand action! The economy needs REAL STIMULUS, not more DEBT. At least $1 Trillion in perpetual Federal tax cuts is necessary: achieved through budget/program cuts. The simplest approach would be to abolish the IRS and the illegitimate Federal Income Tax!

The Federal government would then have an opportunity to figure out alternative ways to perform their Constitutional duties, with the remaining direct/excise taxes. Every government job consumes two private sector jobs (proven), so layoffs will actually CREATE JOBS. I also know significant cuts can be achieved, because the Federal budget use to be $50 Billion/year (Adjusted for Inflation), prior to WWI!!!

For example, volunteer State militias can protect the borders and handle national disasters; tariffs (offsetting foreign wage differentials) can fund essential Military activity (temporarily to resuscitate industry); and the States can establish programs to take care of citizens dependent upon false promises of welfare, by the Federal government.

It will be tough for a year, maybe two - but the alternative is crushing Depression for decades. I choose the former!

Oh, and REPEAL the Federal Reserve Act & RESTORE Sound Money. Problem(s) solved!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I decided to read the article... Mostly out of spite being of the younger generation. I rather wish I had not however. All the media does is portray how horrible life is. After a while you start to believe it. Maybe the headline should read "Thousands of news reporters blamed for influencing depression in millions of people world wide!"

I'm hopeful the media just isn't aware how influential they are and are also unaware of how they're used a tools. This can be witnessed every time Warren Buffet predicts further spiraling of the US stock market. "W. Buffet predicts disaster!", oh look the stock market fell 200 points the next day!

I think the best thing for most people right now would be to put down the rubbish they pick up in the check stands, turn off the computer and instead pick up a book. Preferably one with LOTS of pages and no pictures...

cheers

Good read, but don't blame the Republicans so much. Someone has to plug the credit hole and the sooner, the better. And in additon, who is going to make Obama come clean about his
birth country? It seems he is avoiding answering....he avoids a
lot of eye contact too....he has awarded those irresponsible companies and friends and put a death notice on America.
it

There isn't a great depression here yet. Americans are still way too Pollyanna optimistic. The greatest strength that America has is the cluelessness of its peasants. I would expect that in four years, people will still be "waiting" for GD2. As long as the credit cards are will working, sports is flowing through the cable, and the average peasant still feels "good" about Merica - then all will be well.

Don't forget, in REAL Merica, to admit failure is to admit you're NOT a REAL Merican. That single dilemma will keep the peasants slaving - in silence - for many MANY years.

American peasants might be the dumbest peasants in the world right now.

As an American I have to say there is much truth to this article my only issue is the naive class warfare slant. The truth is that each day more and more Americans are starting to see through the veil of lies that have got us to where we are today and the growth in the nation's despondency is tied to the realization that we are totally lacking in the leadership that could take us in a new direction. Yes the Republicans are bastards and yes the conservative leadership has come from the same circles as the financial robber barons that managed to loot a significant chunk of the countries wealth and ride out into the sunset. But it is the Democrats who are largely responsible for Bankrupting this country by promoting a nanny state in which the public sector unions take and take and take at the expense of the private sector workers. The fact is that the greed bug bit these public sector unions every bit as hard as it did Wall Street and unfortunately their are literally millions more of them than there are bankers in the business of looting from this country. Sound familiar?

Well said. The undertone is there is no Depression at all but simply a War or a Subterfuge. Corporate Profits are skyrocketing but companies are cutting pay and benefits. The whole "bailout" phenom is nothing moer than chicanery to cover the real activity of stealing the remaining wealth and freedom from Americans and transferring these to the corporate elites. The super-rich are doing better than ever. In fact, every year just gets better and better for them. Problem is they comprise

Well spoken, sir! Little to add except to say that there are dozens of developing economies, especially in Africa, still slavishly following the American pattern, and nothing will deter them from this path to destruction.

This very depressing article has a strong vein of truth running through it. American capitalism drowns free enterprise and democracy. Large companies grossly oversell to a gullible public that becomes saddled with extortionate credit, sucking value from the wage slaves that fall for the absurdly named American Dream. There are no commercial messages in the US based on any form of truth, in the absolute sense. It has an economy founded in and awash with lies. I lived in California in the late fifties and early sixties and mixed with all levels of financial success and failure. I came to the conclusion then that most Amercians live in quiet desperation, not daring to express any view that the system is hopelessly flawed. Like the adherents to a religion faced with the truth about its absurdity, they live in a state of denial, not daring to break loose and speak the truth. They worship a god unable to deliver anything, but compelled by brain washing and constant repetition, to maintain 'the faith'.

One great lie, repeated often, is that the US is a democracy. At best it can be called a plutocracy, at worst a kleptocracy.

The unemployment rate is hopelessly distorted. If you have a very good year and then lose your job you don't qualify for unemployment benefit, you have to spend all your money first and then re-apply. Meanwhile the rich get ever richer.

In ancient Rome there was a slaves revolt. The question must be asked, when will the American slaves revolt? It isn't a matter of 'if'.

Comments are now closed on this article