General Vo Nguyen Giap's last battle for the highlands of Vietnam

General Vo Nguyen Giap

The general, a confidante of Ho Chi Minh, who oversaw the siege of Dien Bien Phu and helped repel the Americans is taking on the communist regime over the environment and Chinese influence

BY Tom Fawthrop LAST UPDATED AT 13:46 ON Wed 27 May 2009

In 1954, General Vo Nguyen Giap masterminded a harrowing epic 57-day siege which brought about the crushing defeat of the French empire in Indochina. It was a victory which destroyed the assumption of Western invincibility and inspired anti-colonial struggles all over the world. During the US war Giap was again commander-in-chief, but this time he assumed extra responsibility as the defence minister in Ho Chi Minh's government of North Vietnam.

The amazing supply-line carved out of a 2,000 mile long trail through dense jungle and mountains dubbed the "Ho Chi Minh Trail" was Giap's Initiative. It was to become one of the most bombed roads in the history of warfare. The General also masterminded the final offensive in Spring 1975.

Giap is widely considered to be one of the greatest military leaders of the 20th century - all the more remarkable given that his background was entirely civilian - his early working years were spent as a teacher and a journalist. After the war hard-liners in control of the Vietnamese communist party were jealous of his international stature and intellectual abilities and the war hero was ejected from the politburo in 1982. In 1991 he retired as deputy prime minister.  

The country's most famous soldier is still fighting. This time over the environment.

Now 97, physically frail but still mentally sharp, Giap lives with his wife in an old French colonial house in Hanoi, where he leads a modest existence. He rises at around 5am when he starts his day with breathing exercises before turning into RFI - Radio France International, before listening to the news on Vietnamese stations.

Domestic life is occasionally interrupted by the arrival of various visiting foreign and Vietnamese dignitaries who come to pay their respects. President Lula of Brazil, Hugo Chavez from Venezuela and the South Africa's Thabo Mbeki visited him last year. A number of US politicians have also been to see him, including Robert McNamara his counterpart in the Vietnam War in charge of US Defense Department.

Giap has largely retired from public office apart from holding several honorary roles in associations for Vietnam's war veterans and historians, but the country's most famous soldier is still fighting. This time the battle is over the environment.

The Vietnamese government, eager to keep up the impressive economic growth that was derailed by the global financial crisis, is committed to extracting an estimated 8 billion tonnes of bauxite, the ore which is essential to aluminum production.

Two-thirds of Vietnam's bauxite is to be found in the Central Highlands, a stunningly beautiful and fertile region of thickly forested mountains, coffee plantations and, some argue, an area of enormous eco-tourism potential. There are fears that open-cut mining will destroy vast areas of forest and crops leaving huge deposits of toxic sludge.

Despite Vietnam's long history of conflict with China which briefly invaded the country in 1979, the Chinese aluminum giant Chinalco has been granted a contract for one of the mines. But in January this year, General Giap sent an open letter calling on the government to halt the project.

Giap's stature as a national hero, one-time confidante of late president Ho Chi Minh and one of Vietnam's few untainted politicians is undisputed and the Government realized that they couldn't dismiss him as a mere dissident. Moreover having actively helped Vietnam's ecologists back in the 1980s when he was deputy prime minister, Giap's green credentials are convincing.

According to the scientist, Nguyen Huu Ninh, who was part of a UN team awarded the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize for work on climate change, Giap has a real understanding of ecology. Moreover, "He was our first leader after the war to focus on environmental problems". He has long been fascinated by the green movement. In 1986 a professor returned from a trip to UK with a copy of Schumacher's 'Small is beautiful', one of the Movement's great works and gave it to Giap on a Friday evening; by Monday the General had finished it and was asking for more books on ecology.

So the letter from the 'Green General', which detailed the consequences of the mining proposals in terms of environmental damage, harm to ethnic minorities and even a threat to national security, prompted an unprecedented protest, a rare event in what is still a one-party communist state. It is also rare in a one-party system for such a protest to be reported in the state-owned media. The general's intervention prompted 135 intellectuals to sign a petition to the Vietnamese National Assembly calling for a halt to the project.

In the face of the outcry, Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung, who had described the exploitation of the bauxite as "a major policy of the party and the state", felt he had no choice but to backtrack. Last month, after a hastily convened seminar on the environment, he agreed to scale back the development until a full assessment of the possible environmental impact could be made.

Now opponents have questioned the mines' economic feasibility, given that bauxite processing requires a lot of water and access to cheap electricity, and Vietnam is facing shortages of both. In addition to the environmental concerns, some critics have complained about the presence of hundreds of Chinese workers in the strategic Central Highlands.

Amid the flurry of criticism, which was even joined by his Environment Minister, Dung has now frozen work on one bauxite mine, though he has permitted Chinalco to proceed with another.

General Giap may not win this battle outright but, as always, he is putting up a ferocious fight. · 

Comments

Dear our good Friend, Minh Le,

I respectfully disagree with your comments and thought that it might be just because you're lack of information, the knowledge about the EIA of bauxite mining itself (?). Please go to this comprehensive, non-bias, non-governmental, transparent, independent, complete, scientific website http://www.bauxitevietnam.info/ - to learn more about the cause vs. the effect of the ongoing Bauxite mining projects in the Central Highlands of Vietnam - once and for all. *********

DEAR CITIZENS OF THE WORLD,

Please help stop this destructive, short-sighted ongoing massive Bauxite mining ambition in the Central Highlands of Vietnam. My name is Tran DinhDung and I am currently a volunteer for an international environmental NGO, Viet Ecology Foundation, http://www.vietecology.org. Our organization has just published a petition entitled "Petition For the Immediate Halt On the Bauxite Mining Projects in Central Highlands of Vietnam in the Pending of Environmental Impact Assessments in Accordance with International Treaties and Vietnamese Environmental Laws and Regulations" - which is now being posted at:
http://www.gopetition.com/petitions/stop-bauxite-mining-projects-in-cent...

We sincerely ask for your support and greatly appreciate your kindness if you could further the cause by circulating the Petition to your worldwide networking circles: we're racing to save the UNESCO-recognized Space of Gong Culture, the living treasure of our humankind in the Central Highlands of Vietnam. Thanks so much!*******

"You are responsible for the period of history that you are living in. You have not only the right to choose, but the duty to choose and if you are now surrounded by poverty, by war, by oppression, by cruelty - that is what you have chosen.", Jean-Paul Sartre (1905 - 1980)

I think the first comment from Minh Le make a lot of sense, if you're a junkie. Normal people don't sell every valuable thing they have unless they need to finance some drug habit. Also Minh Le's suggestion for poor family and poor country is brilliant, but what happens when they sold every thing they own and they're still poor, what do they do then? The key for getting rich is not sell all of your natural resources the key is to developed your people. If Vietnam continue on the path of exploiting our natural resources one day we will have nothing, our land and river will be polluted our children and grand children will curse us for leaving them the Southeast Asia version of Haiti.

As a Vietnamese who love his country and his people I don't want to see my country and my people selling cheap raw materials to the Chinese then buying expensive process goods from them. This is at best neo-colonialism and at worst slavery. This is why General Giap is speaking out, I'm sure he doesn't want to be a Chinese slave. Look at what happened to Tibet and her people; don't think for a second that this can't or wont happen to Vietnam.

It is such a funny thing to read the first comment. General Giap is a famous person of the country and he should be a representative for the voices of Vietnamese people who don't want the country to be get worse. Do not be discriminated about the age of a person, just try to have critical thinking, when there is an important project, it should be carefully discussed and debated by different groups in society. Environment is a crucial factor of not only Vietnam but will be a global issue and for our next generation, the technology of China is not good and they are famous of copying the things from the others every one knows, will it be confident to give the future of the environment of the South Vietnam, the rivers and the Mekong Delta for that questioning project?. Think about what the China Govt did in Africa to use the resources in those poor countries, what the China Govt did in their country, how much pollution in China right now and what they will do it in Vietnam? Vietnam is a poor country but just think why it is poor after many years of independence??? It is a big question to be concerned.

Yes, Vietnam is a poor country but as in a poor family,they do not have to sell everything they have in order for living and to be rich. Life is for happiness, and there are more green ways to develop the economy rather than just selling the natural resources, it is a wrong way to do. I do not want to imagine a lot, but for a better Vietnam, we, Vietnamese people should be more critical, more independent and have responsibility with our homeland.

General Giap is now nearly 100 year old (98 to be exact). Do you believe he is still having a sound mind to involve and suggest in this matter. I don't mean to play down the his great contribution and merit to this country and the current Communist Party (he is the hero in my heart). However, please be realistic and see his general health condition recently, you can easily think that he has been taken advantage of his famous to voice up for some interest groups. These groups may compose of some people who really concern about the country security and Chinese immigrant of Vietnam, BUT of majority of reactionary people who want to take this opportunity to humble the government credit. There are also involving some people from overseas who don't have much information and still have prejudice about Vietnam. Please don't use General Giap, a most respected person in Vietnam, for a political game!!!

I think the policy for resource exploitation in Vietnam is a right policy in the current context. Vietnam is a poor countries and just imagine it as a poor family. If it want to have some capital for development, it needs to (or has to) depend on resources to gain some inital capital as a jumb start to finance the development for a brighter future. Like a poor family, you need a jump start capital to find a new jobs or create a small business, so you need to save or sell some things to get the needed capital. The question of resource dependence should not be asked for the poor countries. Vietnam is luckier to have that resources. Moreover, global crisis is knocking every country doors, self saving ourself is needed more than anytimes. So the policy for resource exploitation should be seen as a right policy. Question should be asked here is how to spend and invest this money.

From the current debate on Central Highland exploitation projects, there are two most concerned questions, environment and technology and Chinese influence.

First question on environment and technology is currently investigating and answering. But in my opinion, in current situation with government awareness and also Vietnamese citizen and parliament, question of technology selection is not hard to answer. In fact, the environment pollution depends very much on the selected technology. If technology seclection is solved the environment pollution is minimised its impacts. I think the government has full capacity to choose a good technology that don't affect the environments. In fact, the reforestation of the mining site if done properly can do more good than harm as evident from many other countries.

The second question on Chinese immigrant is really a concern. However, i think it is exaggerated. It few thousand chinese workers are a real concern however, with proper immigration policy this can be solved. Furthermore, the historical and current conflicts with China, settlement of Chinese workers in Vietnam is not easy process as many people think. The lesson of 1978-1979 is still there and vivid. Each Vietnamese is very vigilant to any Chinese living in this country.

Central Highland Mining Exploitation should be the appropriate policy for the current situation. However, the current concern and debate are not without its evidence. If the government can manage the issue of technology and Chinese worker immigrants, it should be good project for Vietnam development

Comments are now closed on this article