McKinnon extradition blocked as May invokes human rights

Gary McKinnon

Hacker Gary McKinnon saved by Theresa May, but why was fellow Asperger's sufferer Talha Ahsan sent to US for trial?

LAST UPDATED AT 13:30 ON Tue 16 Oct 2012

THERESA MAY has saved computer hacker Gary McKinnon from extradition to the United States. The Home Secretary accepted the advice of psychiatrists who said they could not guarantee that McKinnon, who suffers from Asperger’s Syndrome, would not attempt to commit suicide if handed over for trial.

However, celebrations over McKinnon’s victory have been tainted by accusations of racism, because of last week’s extradition to the US of a British Muslim terrorism suspect who also had Asperger’s.

May told MPs that there is no doubt McKinnon is seriously ill, and there was a high risk that he would attempt suicide if extradited. May added that she had carefully examined the medical evidence and taken legal advice and her conclusion was based solely on McKinnon’s human rights.

May’s announcement was met with cheers in the House of Commons. It will now be up to the Director of Public Prosecutions to decide if McKinnon, who had been fighting extradition since 2006, has charges to answer in a UK court. He admits that he hacked into US military computers, but insists he did so to find evidence of UFOs.

At the same time as revealing her decision on McKinnon, May announced, as expected, a shake-up of Britain's extradition agreement with the US which will mean that, in future, people accused of committing a crime in the UK will be more likely to be tried here.

The 'forum bar' will be implemented despite fierce resistance from the US government. It will mean that a court hearing will have to be held to decide where a suspect should stand trial.

Janis Sharp, McKinnon’s mother spoke of her relief, saying: “Thank you, Theresa May, from the bottom of my heart – I always knew you had the strength and courage to do the right thing.”

Shami Chakrabarti, the director of Liberty said: “Extradition should prevent fugitives escaping – not allow for Britons like Gary to be parcelled off around the world based on allegations of offences committed here at home.
“This campaign, led by Gary’s fearless mother, united lawyers, politicians, press and public from across the spectrum in the cause of compassion and common sense.”

Guardian journalist Patrick Wintour suggested that May was more worried about public opinion than any legal arguments., tweeting: “Theresa May (nearly): ‘I have concluded that Mr McKinnon's extradition gave rise to a high risk that I would be demolished by the Daily Mail.’”

While today’s decision has been widely applauded, many have compared McKinnon’s treatment to that of fellow Asperger’s sufferer Talha Ahsan, one of the terrorism suspects extradited to the US last week along with Abu Hamza.

The family of Babar Ahmed, another of the suspects extradited last week, accused May of double standards. “We strongly welcome the decision not to extradite Gary McKinnon - we would not want his family to experience the pain and suffering we have all been enduring since Babar was extradited.

“However, questions do need to be asked as to why, within the space of two weeks, a British citizen with Asperger's accused of computer related activity is not extradited, while two other British citizens, one with Asperger's, engaged in computer related activity are extradited. A clear demonstration of double standards...

“Many of our supporters are angry at what appears to be blatant old-fashioned racism under which all British citizens are equal but some are more equal than others.”

It remains to be seen how the decision will go down in Washington. The BBC's Jane Little says the groundwork had been laid for today's decision, with US policy towards Mr McKinnon "seen to be softening" after President Obama's meeting with David Cameron in 2010 and a comment this summer from government adviser John Arquilla, who said the US should be recruiting elite computer hackers to launch cyber-attacks against terrorists instead of prosecuting them.

However, a foretaste of American reaction was provided by David Rivkin, a former White House counsel to Presidents Reagan and Bush, who told the BBC’s /World at One/ programme that the decision to block extradition was "laughable" and that "under that logic, anybody who claims some kind of physical or mental problem can commit crimes with impunity and get away with it. Because either he would not be prosecuted or extradited". · 

Disqus - noscript

...goodbye Gary - A am sorry that Cameron didn't have the backbone or integrity to stand up for a British citizen! I hope that I am wrong, but I fear not, given Cameron's track record on broken pledges.

Thank God! An MP with principle! If only Cameron and Co would only realise that they were elected to serve the interests of the British public and not to keep jumping through hoops at the mere wave of the hand from the US or the EU! Small hopes though!

The USA is a dysfunctional state, gone mad with some vain idea about World power. They think that they can do anything and get away with it. I am reminded of Rome just before it fell.

Yes, McKinnon is ill. Whatever happens I hope he doesn't attempt suicide, as many of us have been through that and it's not a good place to be. However, they have autistic people in the US and they know their way around the subject. They don't want him for parking in the wrong place, he got into the Pentagon computer and who knows what he might have done. Wouldn't we want an American who had done the equivalent to be extradited to here?

Would be nice if our non-white citizens were afforded the same treatment, Talha Ahsan also has Asperger's syndrome and was extradited last week.

Yes, but he's accused of helping to run jihadi websites! Come on, for people to bring up racism here is reprehensible.

...would be nice if our "non-white" citizens behaved themselves properly in their host country - instead they plan and commit terrorist acts, denounce us as "non-believers", preach hatred to us "non-believers", impose Fatwas on our authors, run paeodphile and under-age prostitution rackets and STILL demand equal (or should I say, preferential?) treatment!. Good riddance to them!

I supported Gary's cause until i heard him speak - there's nothing wrong with him. I'm more aspurges than him.
what a farce. kill himself? how? when?
is it because he's white, non-muslim and doesn't have a long straggly beard?
what a joke

For further concise, balanced comment and analysis on the week's news, try The Week magazine. Subscribe today and get 6 issues completely free.