Instant Opinion: Johnson’s speech was ‘pure Tommy Cooper’
Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Thursday 3 October
The Week’s daily round-up highlights the five best opinion pieces from across the British and international media, with excerpts from each.
1. Michael Deacon in The Daily Telegraph
on comedic comparisons
Boris Johnson brought the house down with a speech that was pure Tommy Cooper
“As it happened, Mr Johnson was speaking in the same venue where Theresa May staggered through the most excruciating humiliation of her premiership, two years ago. It’s hard to avoid the feeling that, had the same misfortunes befallen Mr Johnson – losing his voice, gagging on a cough sweet, the set collapsing about his ears – his audience would have loved it, and laughed all the harder. They would have assumed it was deliberate. Because that’s the other point about Tommy Cooper: half the time, his tricks seemed to be going wrong, comically wrong. And yet the more they seemed to go wrong, the more his fans enjoyed it. The supposed blunders, after all, were simply part of the act. In the end, they felt sure, the great showman would pull off the trick with aplomb. And, indeed, he always did. Mr Johnson’s audience in Manchester seemed to share the same breezy conviction: that for all his goofs and gaffes, he knows exactly what he’s doing. Whether this faith is well placed, we’ll soon find out.
2. Martin Kettle in The Guardian
on the prime minister’s Conference performance
This cowardly speech reveals Boris Johnson’s armoury is empty
“Boris Johnson’s speech to the Conservative party conference was of a piece with his brief and tawdry prime ministership so far. The speech was a scam, an attempt to pretend that inconvenient realities can be wished out of existence by putting on a crowd-pleasing act. Yet these inconvenient realities include such things as the law of the land, the elected parliament, the European Union and the island of Ireland. Between them, these realities have enough clout to foil him.”
3. Stephen Bush in the New Statesman
on breaking the Brexit impasse
Has Boris Johnson actually got a credible alternative to the backstop?
“While it is far from an achievable, real-world proposal; you can still just about see the space for an accord where Downing Street tries to finesse what it wants to sell as a triumphant win for checks away from the border, which is in practice a regulatory border in the Irish Sea. That’s certainly the hope of some in the cabinet – but many on the EU side and in parliament think that Johnson’s real game is blaming the EU to achieve the no-deal Brexit he really wants.”
4. Ahmed Twaij in The Independent
on US healthcare hypocrisy
Bernie Sanders' heart condition can teach us two lessons — one about healthcare and another about Congress
“After the upsetting news that he had been rushed to hospital following chest discomfort earlier today, it was found that Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders had a blocked artery. Emergency surgery has left the Senator for Vermont on the road to recovery — and one thing he will not have to worry about is his medical bill. Given his position in government and income, he can cover the medical costs he is served. However, this incident should serve us as an important reminder of the desperate need for healthcare reform in the US, as well as the inspiring role Sanders himself has in calling for Medicare for all.”
5. David Aaronovitch in The Times
Half-baked health advice breeds ignorance
“Over time I think it’s essential that people believe that public health officials are not trying surreptitiously to nudge or persuade them, but are telling them the truth, caveats and all. The problem is that for this to work greater scientific and statistical literacy among the general population (and journalists more than most) is going to be essential. Otherwise, among a blizzard of claims — to adapt a phrase — we could end up dying of ignorance.”