In Depth

Instant Opinion: Trump vs. Thunberg ‘the battle of our age’

Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Thursday 23 January


The Week’s daily round-up highlights the five best opinion pieces from across the British and international media, with excerpts from each.

1. David Aaronovitch in The Times

on political tribes

Trump v Thunberg is the battle of our age

“Not since the days of Stalin and his pseudo-biologist Lysenko has science been ideologically driven: viruses, resistant bacteria, melting ice caps, the challenge of massive technological change are common problems with common (if complex) solutions. Yet increasingly everything is treated as though it was a matter for partisan contention. We find our camp, locate our tribe and set about the business of mutual reinforcement. The leaders of the tribes gain their positions by telling their audiences how very, very right they are and how very, very wrong are the others.”

2. Sherelle Jacobs in The Daily Telegraph

on climate change extremists

Davos doom-mongers herald a new dark age for climate science

“When did Western civilisation enter this new Dark Age? The creepy scenes of Greta’s machinic protestations at Davos offer a clue. Managerialism, an ideology that has filled the vacuum created by the collapse of communism and post-Seventies disillusionment with market capitalism, infects every corner of society. The twist is that it relies for its survival on the flagrant denial of the chaotic complexity upon which it feeds. It deems that all problems (like all corporations) share more similarities than differences, and can thus be solved through generic, optimised processes. Thus activists like Greta reduce climate change to a clearly diagnosed illness that can be treated by meeting precise deadlines, while the rest of us pay the bill. And thus our elites – who share the same arrogant belief that we have all the expertise to address the Earth’s intricacies – cravenly refuse to acknowledge anything that throws into doubt established ‘facts’. Sadly, until the era of managerialism falls in on itself, we are probably stuck.”

3. Suzanne Moore in The Guardian

on beating Boris Johnson

The left’s top priority: know thine enemy

“Boris Johnson is a chameleon, and modern conservatism is opportunism presented as modernisation: it has an ability to meld wildly different views, and adapt. This new Tory hegemony is not a rerun of Thatcherism or Cameronism, though it has absorbed those things. The left’s response that it is simply a retread is an insult to voters’ intelligence. It is also a refusal to deal with the present. Shouting about austerity and neoliberalism may have felt righteous, but it was never policy.”

4. Janan Ganesh in the Financial Times

on finding the political sweetspot

America is still waiting for a true populist

“In a vaunted age of populism, the US does not have a true populist. No politician of national clout stands for both the economic and cultural sides of the creed. Mr Trump did, more or less, in his 2016 campaign but then — tariffs aside — governed as a Republican supply-sider. Mr Sanders also came close to a balanced populism before softening on immigration. Each man intuited the blend of policies that Americans wanted and decided not to give it to them. The same could be said of much of the political class. The marginal voter appears to crave universal healthcare and higher taxes on the rich, but also tighter borders and less strident identity politics. That ‘but’ is a slander, of course, as no theoretical conflict exists here. It all adds up to a coherent belief in social cohesion under paternalist government. A European would recognise it as Christian Democracy or One Nation Toryism or even Gaullism, but it is just the politics of mid-20th century America, when immigration was low and the welfare state filled out.”

5. Jan-Werner Muller in The New York Times

on left and right politics

Stop comparing Bernie to Trump. It’s ridiculous

“It is high time to retire the horseshoe theory according to which extremes of right and left must always meet somewhere, such that the only salvation from ‘political sociopaths’ lies with the center. Conventional wisdom has it that populists criticize elites. In recent years, with the rise of populists around the globe, there is also the suspicion that they pose a systematic threat to liberal democracy as such. But it is wrong simply to equate populism with being ‘anti-establishment.’ After all, any old civics textbook will say that keeping a critical eye on the powerful is actually a hallmark of being a good democratic citizen, and nothing particularly populist.”

–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––For a weekly round-up of the best articles and columns from the UK and abroad, try The Week magazine. Start your trial subscription today –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––


Religious tolerance, trans treatment and police misogyny
The star of David

Religious tolerance, trans treatment and police misogyny

How London became the city of choice for Russian ‘dirty money’
The City of London skyline
Why we’re talking about . . .

How London became the city of choice for Russian ‘dirty money’

What is a ‘trigger warning’ and why are they controversial?
J.K. Rowling reading from Harry Potter
Getting to grips with . . .

What is a ‘trigger warning’ and why are they controversial?

The possible outcomes of the Sue Gray report
Boris Johnson during a visit to a factory in Anglesey, North Wales
Behind the scenes

The possible outcomes of the Sue Gray report

Popular articles

Are we heading for a snap general election?
Jacob Rees-Mogg
Today’s big question

Are we heading for a snap general election?

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?
Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik
In Depth

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?

Why is New Zealand shutting its borders again?
Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern adjusts her face mask following a press conference
In Depth

Why is New Zealand shutting its borders again?

The Week Footer Banner