In Depth

Coronavirus: are the UK’s Covid plans out of date amid vaccines successes?

Spending watchdog admits Sunak based cut-heavy spending review on forecasts formulated before trial results were in

Chancellor Rishi Sunak has courted controversy with a freeze on public sector pay rises and a reduction in foreign aid spending in his coronavirus pandemic spending review.

The financial statement “pivoted between largesse and pain”, with Sunak announcing that pay will not increase for around 1.3 million public sector workers due to the economic fallout of Covid-19, the Financial Times reports.

In a statement to MPs yesterday, Sunak said the UK’s “health emergency is not yet over and our economic emergency has only just begun”. But the review has come under fire, after the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) revealed that the data used to draw up the plans was published before a string of promising vaccine results emerged.

What figures did the government use?

Tory MPs are “furious” after the spending watchdog admitted that the gloomy “central scenario” forecast on which Sunak’s spending review was based “did not account for the rollout of the immunity jab beginning before Christmas”, the Daily Mail reports. 

Under the out-of-date scenario, the OBR predicted that GDP would shrink by 11.3% this year.

This figure, and Sunak’s review, was based on the assumption of “Britain languishing under virus restrictions until next summer”, with pubs and restaurants in many areas of the country remaining closed, the paper adds.

The chancellor presented his review in the Commons yesterday, two days after the announcement that the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine has been found to be to 90% effectiveness in certain doses. The encouraging results from ongoing Phase 3 clinical trials have raised hopes that the end of the pandemic could come far sooner than had been expected. 

Should the government have adjusted its plans?

It is unclear whether Sunak would have announced different measures had the government used more up-to-date figures. However, the significant differences between the central forecast and other, more optimistic, OBR forecasts might have altered the chancellor’s strategy.

In the OBR’s “best-case scenario” - based on a vaccine being widely available by the spring - GDP “still declines by over 10% this year and the economy takes until the end of next year to recover”, Yahoo! News reports. But in the watchdog’s worst-case scenario, the UK economy shrinks by 12% this year and does not recover until the end of 2024.

In this latter scenario, lockdowns are extended and vaccines prove ineffective.

In a statement yesterday, the OBR said that the announcements last week that the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna vaccines have also achieved “excellent results” in late-stage clinical trials “arrived just as our forecasts were being finalised” and was “undoubtedly very positive news”.

“However, it does not automatically imply an immediate or complete return to normal economic life for the whole population for several reasons,” added the watchdog, which predicts lengthier time-scales for producing, sourcing and administering the jabs.

Recommended

Infection rise prompts European crackdown on vaccine refuseniks
Anti-vaccination sign at protest
Getting to grips with . . .

Infection rise prompts European crackdown on vaccine refuseniks

Will MPs’ pay rise outstrip public sector workers’?
An NHS nurse
Today’s big question

Will MPs’ pay rise outstrip public sector workers’?

Health data, green banking and flawed maps
An MRI scanner
Podcast

Health data, green banking and flawed maps

Quiz of The Week: 17 - 23 July
A sign warning people to self-isolate if contacted by NHS Test and Trace
Quizzes and puzzles

Quiz of The Week: 17 - 23 July

Popular articles

Why your AstraZeneca vaccine may mean no European holidays
Boris Johnson receives his second dose of the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine
Getting to grips with . . .

Why your AstraZeneca vaccine may mean no European holidays

Ten great health, fitness and wellbeing ideas
Woman doing yoga
Advertisement Feature

Ten great health, fitness and wellbeing ideas

How taking the knee began
Colin Kaepernick takes the knee
Getting to grips with . . .

How taking the knee began

The Week Footer Banner