In Brief

Rugby World Cup: England fined for their response to the New Zealand haka

The confrontation set the tone for a pulsating semi-final between England and the All Blacks

England have been fined by World Rugby for their bullish response to New Zealand’s haka in Saturday’s Rugby World Cup semi-final victory. 

Although the amount hasn’t been disclosed, Sky News claims it’s £2,500, a sum that will be donated to charity by the sport’s governing body.

England lined up in a V formation to face down the haka, and six players crossed the halfway line as the All Blacks performed their ritual. 

The confrontation set the tone for a pulsating encounter and World Rugby later uploaded an official video of the incident on YouTube, entitled “England’s incredible response to intense New Zealand haka”. 

More than four million people have viewed the clip and the response has, in the main, been positive.

England players lined up in a V formation for New Zealand’s haka before the Rugby World Cup semi-final

Dan Mullan/Getty Images

Taking control

Former All Blacks fly-half Andrew Mehrtens wrote in The Times that England “took control of the situation”. 

Mehrtens added: “They responded in a way that they knew they were going to but the All Blacks didn’t. Even the time it took to take off their tracksuits will have given them a feeling of control and initiative and that was borne out by the five furious minutes that followed.”

Another person who admired England’s initiative was South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus, who faced the haka several times during his own playing career. 

“I don’t think it was disrespectful,” said Springboks chief Erasmus, whose side face England in this Saturday’s World Cup final.

“It was certainly interesting, it was certainly exciting and it was certainly something new and it brought some spice to the Test match.”

Cultural clash

Nonetheless England have been fined for breaching World Rugby’s “cultural ritual protocol”, introduced after France went nose to nose with the haka in the 2011 Rugby World Cup final.

The fine will lead to more calls among critics of the haka for it to be banned. Last month Irish sports writer Ewan MacKenna made headlines when he wrote an article for Pundit Arena in which he urged World Rugby to stop “pandering to the dance”, which he said had been “completely overdone” for commercial reasons. 

There followed the inevitable social media storm, but Mackenna refused to retract the statement, posting a video on Twitter of how the All Blacks used to approach the haka, along with the message: “I’ve enraged the idiocy of New Zealand. ‘Heritage’. ‘Pride’. ‘Warriors’. ‘History’. ‘Culture’. Eh no, it’s marketing and exploitation.”

Rugby World Cup further reading

Recommended

A guide to the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics
A lantern containing the Olympic flame for the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics
In Depth

A guide to the Beijing 2022 Winter Olympics

Novak Djokovic: a poster boy for anti-vaxxers?
A ‘Thanks Djoko’ placard at a demonstration against health passes and Covid-19 vaccines in Paris on 15 January
Why we’re talking about . . .

Novak Djokovic: a poster boy for anti-vaxxers?

Six Nations 2022: fixtures, squads and predictions
Wales celebrate winning the Six Nations in 2021
In Depth

Six Nations 2022: fixtures, squads and predictions

Virat Kohli and Joe Root: a tale of two cricket captains
Joe Root and Virat Kohli
Profile

Virat Kohli and Joe Root: a tale of two cricket captains

Popular articles

Best new TV crime dramas of 2022
Hidden Assets BBC
In Depth

Best new TV crime dramas of 2022

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?
Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik
In Depth

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?

Why is the UK in pole position to emerge from Covid-19 first?
A woman wearing a face mask waits for the tube in London
Today’s big question

Why is the UK in pole position to emerge from Covid-19 first?

The Week Footer Banner