Rihanna video: torture porn provokes pop debate
Explicit revenge fantasy has shocked commentators, but is Rihanna part of a worrying trend?
The video for Rihanna's latest single, Bitch Better Have My Money, marks either a new low in popular culture, or an inventive take on feminine power.
Critics have been divided by the seven-minute video, often abbreviated to BBHMM, which features Rihanna's character seeking revenge on a rich man who owes her a debt.
She gets even by kidnapping, stripping, torturing and killing the man's wife, played by Canadian supermodel Rachel Roberts.
Subscribe to The Week
Escape your echo chamber. Get the facts behind the news, plus analysis from multiple perspectives.
Sign up for The Week's Free Newsletters
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
From our morning news briefing to a weekly Good News Newsletter, get the best of The Week delivered directly to your inbox.
While much of the violence is implied and unseen, the wife is depicted topless, strung up in a warehouse, being forced to take drugs and eventually being drowned. It's a graphic revenge fantasy, but one shot in the glamorous style of a fashion shoot.
Sarah Vine in the Daily Mail called the video "repulsive" and an "endless stream of filthy, violent and downright misogynistic images". She adds that the song, which "glorifies murder, torture, drug-taking, guns and racial stereotyping", should "turn all mother's stomachs".
In The Observer, Barbara Ellen has both artistic and moral objections to the song. She says that Rihanna has produced better songs than "this (sub-Sia ear-dung)", and the video "comes across as a painfully obvious self-indulgent attempt to revive industry interest in her God-awful acting". Ellen's main objection to the video is the "pure misogyny".
But Rachel Roberts defends the video in which she appears, telling The Guardian she was aware that the violence and nudity would prove controversial. "Obviously, it's risque," she says, "but there are a lot of films, say Tarantino's, that are far more graphic and violent."
She also argues that the song is empowering, saying: "Rihanna is portraying a strong woman, who is fighting back, even if her methods are obviously highly questionable."
Rebecca Carroll, also in The Guardian, agrees. She argues that the backlash has come because the black woman is in control. To be sure, the video is "vividly violent", says Carroll, it's "an unabashed revenge fantasy". But she also argues that the violence is equivalent to a Tarantino film.
But Tarantino, is a white, male director, and Rihanna is "masterly ambitious black woman with a fear of nothing and no one". Carroll notes that Rihanna has the agency to create her music and direct her career on her own, and that's what should matter.
In the Daily Telegraph, Alex Proud is unconvinced, calling the video "puerile, sexist, race-bait nonsense". Actually, he says, it's not that shocking because it's "courting controversy by numbers", but it is a sign of a more worrying trend.
He goes on to say that the video is a "seven-minute-long softcore snuff film" and evidence of how "the porniness of videos has ratcheted up over the years". Yes, people can call it feminist if it makes them feel better, he says, but the main point is that "kids don't need any more porn".
Create an account with the same email registered to your subscription to unlock access.
Sign up for Today's Best Articles in your inbox
A free daily email with the biggest news stories of the day – and the best features from TheWeek.com
-
The Week Unwrapped: Sudan, tackling homelessness and fake news
Podcast What is happening in Sudan? Could London really end rough sleeping? And why has Joe Lycett being making up stories?
By The Week Staff Published
-
Taylor Swift's surprise double album: an event of 'world-shaking proportions'
Why Everyone's Talking About Fans are 'reeling' after The Tortured Poets Department is followed by The Anthology – 15 additional tracks
By Julia O'Driscoll, The Week UK Published
-
Quiz of The Week: 13 - 19 April
Puzzles and Quizzes Have you been paying attention to The Week's news?
By Rebecca Messina, The Week UK Published
-
Miss Universe 2023: win for inclusion or nothing to celebrate?
Talking Point Beauty pageant included mothers, plus-sized models and trans women – but fails to distract from global conflict
By Harriet Marsden, The Week UK Published
-
Barbie: from problematic toy to feminist icon?
Talking Point She may have exacerbated negative body image issues among girls but Barbie also offered a diverse range of career choices
By Sorcha Bradley Published
-
Why today’s puritanism is latest example of moral panic around naked women
feature Scantily clad celebrities are once again being presented as a threat to wider society
By The Week Staff Published
-
Mary Wollstonecraft sculpture condemned as ‘naked silver Barbie’
Speed Read Maggi Hambling’s statue is intended to represent the feminist icon’s imagination
By Holden Frith Last updated
-
Phoebe Waller-Bridge: five things you didn’t know about the Fleabag star
In Depth Emmy winner signs £50m Amazon deal
By James Ashford Last updated
-
Seven best books on feminism
In Depth From Virginia Woolf to Roxane Gay, here are The Week’s top picks of feminist literature and non-fiction
By The Week Staff Published
-
Method in the madness: The Met Ball's key looks
In Depth All the trends from fashion's biggest night of the year
By The Week Staff Published
-
Airbnb rentals with A-list guests
Speed Read Stay in the luxury homes that have hosted Beyonce, Rihanna and Emma Stone
By The Week Staff Published