Pros and cons

Brexit: the pros and cons of leaving the EU

The arguments for and against Britain’s decision to leave the European Union

Two years after the UK formally left the European Union on 31 January 2020, and a year after the country officially exited the single market and customs union, the long-term benefits and costs of Brexit are still far from clear.

To mark the occasion Prime Minister Boris Johnson released plans for a so-called Brexit Freedoms Bill, which the government says will “cut £1bn of red tape for businesses, ease regulatory burdens” and ultimately clear the hurdles that are blocking its “mission to unite and level up the country”.

In a celebratory article in the Daily Mail, Johnson argued that on Brexit’s second anniversary, “we have all kinds of reasons to celebrate our new freedoms”, hailing the “very big things” the UK has achieved since leaving the bloc. 

“We have taken back control of our money, our borders and our laws. We have done more than 60 free trade deals,” Johnson claimed, as he hailed being out of the Common Agricultural Policy and the Common Fisheries Policy, and removed from “all the vexation and delay of EU procurement rules”. 

But with many trade deals still to agree, and mammoth queues of lorries outside Dover, the road ahead could prove bumpy. 

1

Sovereignty

For Brexiteers, sovereignty was seen as a simple win: even the most ardent Remainers had to admit that EU membership involved giving up some control over domestic affairs. They shared the view that EU institutions drained power from the UK parliament. For Leavers, exiting the EU would allow Britain to re-establish itself as a truly independent nation with connections to the rest of the world.

For Remainers, it would result in the country giving up its influence in Europe, turning back the clock and retreating from the global power networks of the 21st century. To them, EU membership involved a worthwhile exchange of sovereignty for influence: in return for agreeing to abide by EU rules, they said, Britain had a seat around the negotiating table and its voice was amplified on the world stage as a result.

This week Attorney General Suella Braverman said the new Brexit Freedoms Bill would be “key to us taking charge of our regained sovereignty”. It will mean the country can move away from “outdated EU laws” that resulted from “unsatisfactory compromises within the EU, some of which the UK voted and lobbied against – but was required to adopt without question”.

And, nearly a year after Johnson set out his plans for a Global Britain, Rusi research fellow Ed Arnold said the current crisis in Ukraine will serve as an opportunity for the UK to “demonstrate exactly what Global Britain means and how it intends to develop as a post-Brexit European security actor”.

2

Northern Ireland

Before his resignation in December 2021, the Brexit Minister Lord Frost proposed reforms to the Northern Ireland Protocol, which was where he felt most of the “current friction” between Britain and the EU stemmed. Whether or not attempting to renegotiate the deal was an attempt to “wind the clock back to arguments that were lost in 2019”, as Peter Foster argued in the Financial Times, it is clear that the protocol as it stands is far from sufficient. 

Northern Ireland has been plunged into a political crisis after Stormont’s agriculture minister, Edwin Poots of the DUP, ordered a halt to Brexit checks on goods coming into Northern Ireland from Great Britain, reported the BBC.

That was followed by the resignation of the DUP First Minister Paul Givan. “The DUP said Givan’s departure, which is effective immediately, was in protest at the Northern Ireland protocol, which creates a trade border between the country and the rest of the UK,” said The Guardian.

Under power-sharing rules, his resignation meant that Michelle O’Neill of Sinn Fein also had to step down to avoid one-party rule. The departure of the co-chairs of the Stormont executive “is a serious blow to local government and will freeze decision-making on budget matters, healthcare and energy bill grants”, said the paper. 

3

Vaccine rollout

Johnson argued this week that the UK was the first to start vaccinating its citizens against Covid-19 “at least partly because of Brexit”. He claimed in the Daily Mail that the UK is “coming out of Covid faster than virtually any other European country” due to the successful vaccine rollout. “We were only able to do so because we chose to forge our own path as an independent United Kingdom,” he said. 

However, this claim has come under scrutiny. The country’s ability to press ahead with a new vaccine was “actually permitted under EU law”, something that the UK’s own medicines regulator, the MHRA, has confirmed, said the BBC

Under European law, a vaccine must be approved for use by the European Medicines Agency (EMA), “but individual countries can use an emergency procedure that allows them to distribute a vaccine for temporary use in their domestic market”, said the broadcaster. At the time, the UK was in the post-Brexit “transition period” and therefore still subject to EU rules anyway.

Although there certainly would have been “political pressure” for EU members to conform to a bloc-wide agreement to “move as one” on vaccines, there was no legal obligation to do so, said Channel 4 News’s FactCheck service.

4

Immigration

Under EU law, Britain could not prevent a citizen of another member state from coming to live in the UK, and Britons benefited from an equivalent right to live and work anywhere else in the bloc. The result was a huge increase in immigration into Britain, particularly from eastern and southern Europe.

When the referendum took place in June 2016, net migration hit an all-time record of 333,000, with net migration of EU citizens estimated to be 184,000. Many Remainers acknowledged that the pace of immigration had led to some difficulties with housing and service provision, but said the net effect had been overwhelmingly positive. By contrast, Brexiteers said Britain should “regain control” of its borders. Most wanted a substantial cut in immigration, although some said it was less about numbers than the principle of national sovereignty.

Since then, immigration “has become a much less salient political issue, and public attitudes towards immigration have become more positive”, wrote Jonathan Portes for the Oxford Review of Economic Policy. “However, its economic significance has become more apparent, first as migration flows from the EU fell sharply and then, in the past year, as the Covid-19 pandemic has led to very large net outflows.”

The latest statistics from the Office for National Statistics show that net migration “fell considerably” in 2020 to around 34,000, “likely caused by a combination of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic and Brexit”. Net migration for EU nationals was negative, with 94,000 more EU nationals estimated to have left the UK than to have arrived.

5

Jobs

Pro-EU campaigners put economic security at the heart of their message, claiming three million jobs would be lost if Britain voted to leave. But Brexiteers branded the campaign “Project Fear”, dismissing it as a collection of gloomy fantasies. Those two simple positions masked a complex debate about economic forecasts and employment rates, which intersected with arguments about trade policy and migration.

Take immigration, for example. Fewer people coming to the UK would mean less competition for jobs among those who remained and, potentially, higher wages – a point conceded by Stuart Rose, leader of the pro-Remain Britain Stronger in Europe campaign. “But that is not necessarily a good thing,” Rose said, as labour shortages and rising wage bills could reduce economic competitiveness and growth.

Reduced immigration could also cause damaging skills shortages in the UK workforce, said Remainers, as well as dampen demand for goods and services. Writing for the London School of Economics, Professor Adrian Favell said limiting freedom of movement would deter the “brightest and the best” of the continent from coming to Britain. Brexiteers, meanwhile, said Britain could tailor its post-Brexit immigration policy to the needs of the economy.

Business leaders have warned that a lack of EU and overseas workers will “put a brake on the UK’s economic recovery from Covid-19” and could raise prices of goods as staff shortages force employers to offer higher wages.

British agriculture has also been severely hit, said Euronews. A 2018 report by the Migration Advisory Committee found that 99% of seasonal workers in British agriculture were from EU countries, and many have not returned since the end of freedom of movement. 

6

Trade and investment

The EU is a single market in which imports and exports between member states are exempt from tariffs and other barriers. Services, including financial services, can also be offered without restriction across the continent. The consequences of Brexit for businesses that took advantage of these freedoms was always a matter of debate and conjecture.

“More than 50% of our exports go to EU countries,” said Sky News during the referendum campaign, and membership meant we had a say over how trading rules were drawn up. Within the EU, Britain also benefited from trade deals between the EU and other world powers (now including Canada and Japan, which have both concluded free-trade deals with the EU since the UK voted to leave).

Outside the EU, said Remainers, the UK would lose the benefits of free trade with neighbours and reduce its negotiating power with the rest of the world. Brexiteers, meanwhile, said the UK could compensate for those disadvantages by establishing its own trade agreements – and that most small and medium-sized firms, which have never traded overseas, would be freed of the regulatory burden that comes with EU membership.

So far the UK has signed around 70 trade deals and agreements in principle with other countries, and one with the EU.

But, as the BBC reported in October 2021, the majority of these deals are “rollover” deals, which copy the terms of the deals the UK already had when it was an EU member, “rather than creating new benefits”.

The UK signed a trade deal with Australia in December 2021, the first negotiated from scratch since the UK left the EU, which the UK government said would “unlock £10.4 billion of additional trade”. The UK has also signed new trade deals with Japan as well as an agreement with Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein. 

Politico reported that the Australia deal would add just “0.08 percent to British wealth (GDP) by 2035”, around a “£2.3 billion annual boost to the U.K.”. 

But any potential boost to the economy is “lower than the cost to British GDP as a result of leaving the EU”, the news site said.

And others fear the true economic benefit of trade deals that have been negotiated so far could be far lower, giving a tiny 0.01% boost to GDP, according to analysis from The Independent. The benefits of the deal are “dwarfed by the economic hit from leaving the EU, which the government estimates at 4 per cent of GDP over the same period”, said the paper.

7

Levelling up

On the publication of the long-awaited levelling-up white paper on Wednesday, Michael Gove, the levelling up secretary, said the Brexit referendum was – in part – a call from the public to change the economic model of the UK. 

“The Brexit referendum was a wake-up call,” Gove told Sky News. “As well as a clear commandment to leave the European Union it was also a way of saying to people in SW1, people like me: ‘Look, it’s vital that you change the economic model of this country.

“It’s all very well if people are in London and the south-east in financial services and others do well, we don’t begrudge that. But you’ve got to listen to us,’” The Guardian reported.

The white paper details the government’s plans to improve services such as education, broadband and transport, which it says will take until 2030.

At the “heart of the strategy” is a plan to create more regional mayors, much like the existing post held by Labour’s Andy Burnham in Greater Manchester, the Conservatives’ Andy Street in the West Midlands and Ben Houchen in Tees Valley, said the BBC.

But Labour has criticised the plans for containing  “no new money and little fresh thinking”, according to the broadcaster.

More on Brexit

Good Friday Agreement: what is it and is it at risk?
Tony Blair and Bertie Ahern, the Irish PM
In Depth

Good Friday Agreement: what is it and is it at risk?

Northern Ireland Protocol: is there hope for a ‘landing zone’?
Sinn Féin’s Michelle O’Neill
Today’s big question

Northern Ireland Protocol: is there hope for a ‘landing zone’?

Will the US save the Northern Ireland Protocol?
Joe Biden has repeatedly warned the UK against jeopardising the Good Friday Agreement
Talking point

Will the US save the Northern Ireland Protocol?

The Northern Ireland Protocol explained
David Frost and Boris Johnson
Fact file

The Northern Ireland Protocol explained

How likely is a united Ireland?
Sinn Féin deputy leader Michelle O'Neill with party leader Mary Lou McDonald
In Brief

How likely is a united Ireland?

How to renew a UK passport
Blue and burgundy UK passports
In Depth

How to renew a UK passport

Can the prime minister be arrested?
Boris Johnson
In Depth

Can the prime minister be arrested?

The highs and lows of Boris Johnson’s time as prime minister
Boris Johnson and Carrie Symonds in Downing Street after the election victory
In Depth

The highs and lows of Boris Johnson’s time as prime minister

Unboxed: rebranded Festival of Brexit an ‘irresponsible use of public money’
An Unboxed installation
Why we’re talking about . . .

Unboxed: rebranded Festival of Brexit an ‘irresponsible use of public money’

A post-Brexit Big Bang? 
Jacob Rees-Mogg: ‘reality-bending powers’
Why we’re talking about . . .

A post-Brexit Big Bang? 

Jacob Rees-Mogg on mission to ‘turbo-charge’ the benefits of Brexit
Jacob Rees-Mogg
Behind the scenes

Jacob Rees-Mogg on mission to ‘turbo-charge’ the benefits of Brexit

‘Like Kate and Meghan, Margaret and Elizabeth were reduced to stereotypes’
Princess Margaret and Queen Elizabeth
Instant Opinion

‘Like Kate and Meghan, Margaret and Elizabeth were reduced to stereotypes’

What’s happening in Northern Ireland
Paul Givan
The latest on . . .

What’s happening in Northern Ireland

What the Brexit Freedoms Bill means for the UK
Houses of Parliament
Getting to grips with . . .

What the Brexit Freedoms Bill means for the UK

What is Tony Blair up to now?
Tony Blair allegedly made the claim to Trump’s son-in-law during a White House visit
In Depth

What is Tony Blair up to now?

Truss handed ‘poisoned fruit’ of Brexit brief after Frost’s exit
Liz Truss
Behind the scenes

Truss handed ‘poisoned fruit’ of Brexit brief after Frost’s exit

‘The future of UK-EU relations depends on the fate of Boris Johnson’
Boris Johnson
Instant Opinion

‘The future of UK-EU relations depends on the fate of Boris Johnson’

What Starmer’s reshuffle means for Labour
Keir Starmer
Between the lines

What Starmer’s reshuffle means for Labour

Crunch-time for British trade 
Boris Johnson speaks at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet
Why we’re talking about . . .

Crunch-time for British trade 

What is Article 16?
Arrival of goods, Northern Ireland
Today’s big question

What is Article 16?

How Brexit handed a ‘financial boon’ to former Soviet state Estonia
Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas
In Depth

How Brexit handed a ‘financial boon’ to former Soviet state Estonia

Why the UK is suffering a Walkers crisps shortage
Walkers crisps on a supermarket shelf
The latest on . . .

Why the UK is suffering a Walkers crisps shortage

The post-Brexit fishing dispute explained
Fishing boats in the channel
Getting to grips with . . .

The post-Brexit fishing dispute explained

The war plan for post-Brexit fish fight with France
French fishermen in the Channel
Behind the scenes

The war plan for post-Brexit fish fight with France

The Week Footer Banner