Media

What is cultural appropriation and how can you spot it?

Controversial claims of cultural appropriation are becoming increasingly commonplace

Levelled at everyone from university students at fancy dress parties to high-end fashion brands, accusations of cultural appropriation have become a common occurrence over the past few years.

Wearing a Native American headdress as a costume, for example, might once not have raised any eyebrows, but is now often frowned upon.

In January, the Japanese fashion brand Comme des Garcons was forced to apologise after it was accused of cultural appropriation at Paris Fashion Week. During the offending show, mostly white models took to the catwalk wearing cornrow wigs.

This followed accusations that Dolce & Gabbana had trivialised Chinese culture in a campaign in 2018 and a backlash against Gucci for dressing all-white models in Sikh-style turbans in 2016.

Cultural appropriation has been “steadfastly called out” in fashion, says The Telegraph, thanks to the rise of social media, but it’s not just clothes and hair styles that can be co-opted. Similar controversies have cropped up in all aspects of culture, from the arts, to food and dance.

So what exactly is cultural appropriation?

Oxford Dictionaries, which only put the phrase into its official lexicon in 2017, defines cultural appropriation as “the unacknowledged or inappropriate adoption of the customs, practices, ideas, etc. of one people or society by members of another and typically more dominant people or society.”

Simply put, it is when someone adopts something from a culture that is not his or her own – a hairstyle, a piece of clothing, a manner of speaking, even a type of exercise (yoga, for example).

But, says the EverydayFeminism website, that’s not the whole story. Unlike cultural exchange, in which there is a mutual interchange, appropriation refers to a “particular power dynamic in which members of a dominant culture take elements from a culture of people who have been systematically oppressed by that dominant group”.

Originally derived from sociologist writing in the 1990s, “its usage appears to have first been adopted by indigenous peoples of nations tainted by histories of colonisation, such as Canada, Australia and the United States”, says The Tablet.

What’s wrong with it?

It’s often fine to take on aspects of another culture, argues Quartz writer Jenni Avins, whether it’s putting on espadrilles or making coffee with an Italian espresso machine. Simply getting ready in the morning is a “daily act of cultural appropriation and I’m not the least bit sorry about it”, she says.

The problem arises when somebody takes something from another less dominant culture in a way that members of that culture find undesirable and offensive. The point is that the more marginalised group doesn’t get a say, while their heritage is deployed by someone in a position of greater privilege – for fun or fashion, perhaps, and out of a place of ignorance rather than knowledge of that culture.

Wearing espadrilles to work is therefore different from wearing a sombrero to a Halloween party or sending a series of white models down the catwalk wearing their hair in cornrows.

As Dr Adrienne Keene of Native Appropriations tells EverydayFeminism, “You are pretending to be a race that you are not and are drawing upon stereotypes to do so.”

Can it work the other way around?

Yes, it can and does – but usually in a different way. Often a more marginalised culture will adopt aspects of the stronger in order to fit in, not stand out. Black women, for example, frequently report they feel unable to leave their hair in its natural state. The BBC cites cases of women being told by employers it looks “unprofessional”. Some say they must spend time and money to make it more like “white hair”, HuffPost reports.

Again, it comes down to an imbalance in power. The black women in this example are not adopting elements of another culture for fun or even necessarily out of choice, but in order to avoid discrimination by the more dominant group. Again, it all comes down to cultural power, historic and modern.

–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––For a round-up of the most important stories from around the world - and a concise, refreshing and balanced take on the week’s news agenda - try The Week magazine. Start your trial subscription today –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

Recommended

‘Sleazy Access’
Today's newspaper front pages
Today’s newspapers

‘Sleazy Access’

Woman wants Prince Harry arrested for not marrying her
Tall Tales

Woman wants Prince Harry arrested for not marrying her

How the world reported the UK’s ‘joyful’ lockdown easing
Drinkers outside a pub in Windsor
Global lens

How the world reported the UK’s ‘joyful’ lockdown easing

Revealed: Prince Philip was fascinated by UFOs
prince-philip-hospital01.jpg
Tall Tales

Revealed: Prince Philip was fascinated by UFOs

More on Cultural appropriation

Why is blackfishing so controversial?
Kim Kardashian
In Depth
22 May 2020

Why is blackfishing so controversial?

Social media influencers including Kim Kardashian-West accused of faking their racial background
Why everyone’s talking about American Dirt
american_dirt.jpg
In Depth
4 Feb 2020

Why everyone’s talking about American Dirt

Jeanine Cummins novel criticised as ‘cultural appropriation’ and ‘opportunistic’
Stay woke: what is wokeness?
Laurence Fox
In Depth
21 Jan 2020

Stay woke: what is wokeness?

Laurence Fox latest to dismiss ‘woke’ culture
What is white privilege?
Trevor Noah
Daily Briefing
4 Apr 2019

What is white privilege?

US talk show host Trevor Noah praised for his impassioned explanation