In Depth

‘Time is up for Boris Johnson’s reckless optimism’

Your digest of analysis and commentary from the British and international press

1

Clare Foges in The Times

Time is up for Johnson’s reckless optimism

on the Christmas U-turn

“The past nine months have seen a tug-of-war in Westminster between sober caution and something-will-turn-up optimism, the scientists and Sir Keir Starmer heaving on one side while our prime minister heaves on the other. Time and again Boris Johnson has pulled government tone and policy on to the side of optimism, before events brutally yank it back again. His fierce desire to cheer people up has led to a series of over-promises; his fierce aversion to bearing bad news has delayed difficult but inevitable decisions... He has repeatedly dismissed Starmer as an unpatriotic Eeyore who lacks the requisite Blitz spirit and belief in Britain to face down the virus, only belatedly to follow the Labour leader’s prescriptions.”

2

Tom Chivers on UnHerd

How dangerous is the Covid mutation?

on a new threat

“Here’s what I’ve learned. In short: it’s real; we need to take it seriously, and watch it closely, and it will likely make life harder; but it’s not panic stations, and there’s no major reason as yet to think it will, for instance, stop vaccines from working. Also, we’ve been oddly lucky with the testing. First: there really is a new, noticeably different strain. Ewan Birney, the deputy director-general of the European Molecular Biology Laboratory, points out that all viruses mutate, all the time. Some, such as HIV and influenza, mutate incredibly rapidly, making it very hard to create vaccines against them. SARS-Cov2 is ‘pedestrian’ by comparison, he says, but still, new mutations arise all the time, and we don’t bother with a press conference for every one. ‘If we did, we wouldn’t be able to move for press conferences,’ he says. The new strain, though, really has mutated significantly more.”

3

Tom Harwood in The Daily Telegraph

Britain is being punished for alerting the world to a new crisis

on spotting the mutation first

“Politics, not science appears to be leading the majority of European countries’ response. How a shutdown in the days before Christmas would prevent a virus strain that the data shows has been merrily replicating since at least September from transmitting is not clear. The French, angry over the United Kingdom’s insistence to control its own waters, have taken an especially draconian approach. While Ireland, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, and Belgium have impeded the movement of people, not goods, Macron’s administration seems to have taken a particular delight in halting freight as well as travellers. While most countries are making exceptions for cargo, the French – for now – are putting a stop to it. What is clear is that this political disruption comes at the time of crunch talks over issues of borders, movement, and trade. It is disappointing, if not surprising, that obstinate partners in these talks have now found a convenient excuse to pull up the drawbridge.”

4

Mujtaba Rahman in The Guardian

Europe's UK travel ban is not a punishment for Brexit

on the politics of health

“France announced its travel ban after a two-hour meeting of the defence council – chaired remotely by Macron, who is still recovering from the virus himself. The move has sparked allegations by UK Brexiteers, including Nigel Farage, that this was intended to ‘bully’ Britain into an EU trade deal. These claims are unfounded. French officials dismissed them this morning as ‘a lamentable fantasy’... Though we are used to crises over Britain’s trade with the EU, this latest one is simply based on the natural concerns our European neighbours have about the mutant strain of Covid-19 taking root in their own countries. As a senior French source said: ‘We and other EU countries were given little choice by the alarmist tone of the UK government’s own communications on the issue. If London was ordering its own citizens not to leave the south-east, how could we allow travel across the Channel to continue normally?’”

5

Professor Gabriel Scally in The Independent

Government indecision is the UK’s greatest health threat

on leading by example

“It is the most deprived communities in the UK that have most to fear from continued and resurgent spread of Covid-19. Despite this having been clear in England from the early days of the pandemic, local authorities in England have not been given the necessary resources. They are unable to mount an effective outbreak response, nor are they able to ensure that adequate preventive measures are put in place. In particular, the absence of an effective Find, Test, Trace, Isolate and Support system leaves local communities, including their schools and places of work, extraordinarily vulnerable to rapid and lethal spread of Covid-19. Given the enormous death toll in the UK and the lack of an effective government response so far, it will take a major strategic shift for the government to respond effectively to the steadily worsening situation. We absolutely need the Westminster government to make that shift. If it continues to pursue the policies that have failed so far, it is inevitable that they will fail again.”

Recommended

What is Donald Trump up to now?
Donald Trump
In Depth

What is Donald Trump up to now?

Quiz of The Week: 16 - 22 October
Boris Johnson watches as a booster jab is administered in Little Venice, London
Quizzes and puzzles

Quiz of The Week: 16 - 22 October

‘Many more people are realising how bad England’s Covid situation is’
Boris Johnson
Instant Opinion

‘Many more people are realising how bad England’s Covid situation is’

‘If anyone can save Joe Biden, it’s Donald Trump’
Trump at October 2021 rally
Global lens

‘If anyone can save Joe Biden, it’s Donald Trump’

Popular articles

The tally of Covid-19 vaccine deaths examined
Boy receiving Covid vaccine
Getting to grips with . . .

The tally of Covid-19 vaccine deaths examined

What is blackfishing?
Shot of Jesy Nelson with her hair in braids
In Depth

What is blackfishing?

Why does the UK have highest Covid case rate in western Europe?
England lockdown lifted
Today’s big question

Why does the UK have highest Covid case rate in western Europe?

The Week Footer Banner