Instant Opinion

‘Arlene Foster’s demise signals we must strengthen pragmatic unionism’

Your digest of analysis and commentary from the British and international press

1

James Forsyth in The Times

Boris Johnson will make Ulster the EU’s problem

on a fragile unionism

“Whenever unionism feels it can’t trust the British government it goes into an angry, pessimistic, almost paranoid state of mind and Arlene Foster felt the brunt of that,” writes James Forsyth in The Times. While she may have been “doomed” by her “ambivalence” on gay conversion therapy, ultimately “the DUP felt it was haemorrhaging votes because its leader had been duped by No. 10” over promises there would be no Irish Sea border. “It needed to staunch the bleeding.” The unionist vote is now split, and Sinn Fein could emerge as the largest party at next year’s Stormont elections. “It is hard to see how power-sharing between unionists and nationalists could survive if Sinn Fein became the largest party,” argues Forsyth. It is therefore “in the interests of London, Dublin and Brussels to strengthen pragmatic unionism: Foster’s demise is a sign of what happens when this is forgotten”.

2

Camilla Cavendish in the Financial Times

Westminster redecorating could tarnish Johnson’s carefree image

on the real national treasure

“British politics currently resembles a whodunnit, with Westminster consumed by one question: who paid to redecorate the prime minister’s Downing Street flat?” writes Camilla Cavendish in the Financial Times. Boris Johnson will not be brought down by “wallpaper-gate” alone, “but if the impression keeps growing that Britain is run by a gilded chumocracy, it could prove toxic at the next election”. “The most damaging aspect may prove to be not the cover-up, but the snub to a national treasure, the John Lewis department store”, Cavendish adds. “To diss John Lewis… is to attack an institution which has served Middle England from cradle to grave.” The store’s “genius is to be faintly upmarket but not flashy, as voters might once have seen Boris”.

3

John Ferry in The Spectator

Scotland’s post-reality politics

on political unrealities 

“When the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) uses the word ‘disappointing’ in its press release, you know things are getting serious,” writes John Ferry in The Spectator. That’s how it described the manifestos of Scotland’s three biggest political parties – the Scottish National Party, Scottish Labour and the Scottish Conservatives. According to the IFS, all failed to “provide transparent and comprehensive costings for their plans”. As the IFS makes clear, “the spending commitments are a fantasy. None of the big parties are talking anywhere about cuts or increases in taxes… In this sense they fit perfectly into the groove of contemporary Scottish politics, which exists in a kind of la-la land of unrecognised truths and rehearsed pretences.” Scottish Labour and the Tories know they are merely competing to be the biggest opposition party. “Why not then go all-in on pledges?” Ferry asks. “As for the SNP, they know they can promise the Earth and outsource the blame to Westminster when they later fail to deliver.”

4

Marcus Shepheard in The Guardian

The government dithers and delays, but the UK needs a Covid public inquiry now

on pandemic accountability

“It is time for a public inquiry,” says Marcus Shepheard in The Guardian. “The coronavirus crisis has been an extraordinary period for the UK, and the toll substantial,” he says, but “the lack of an inquiry has created a vacuum in the discourse around the crisis” that has “been filled with a briefing war, and a blame game of anonymous comments and contradictory statements. This is unhelpful and only undermines public confidence.” Shepheard continues: “Accountability matters. Despite what the government says, investigations by the National Audit Office or parliamentary select committees – while all valuable – are no substitute for a public inquiry.” This, he adds, “will not be easy, or quick, but it is vital. The prime minister should act now.”

5

Cathy Newman in The Independent

Why haven’t we paid as much attention to the Post Office scandal as we have to Boris Johnson’s flat?

on overlooked injustice

“Every waking hour, many journalists and politicians in the Westminster bubble are consumed by the prime minister’s Lulu Lytle home furnishings,” writes Cathy Newman in the Independent. “But the scandal which should be keeping us all awake at night is the appalling miscarriage of justice which saw more than 700 Post Office workers wrongly accused of theft, fraud and false accounting.” The coverage of the Post Office debacle “raises uncomfortable questions about the priorities of sections of the media and political classes,” she says. The scandal is “one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British history”, yet “the story has almost entirely disappeared from the front pages and the broadcast news bulletins”. “It’s not that we care too much about allegations of sleaze concerning the prime minister,” Newman adds. “It’s that over the years we appear to have cared too little about allegations which wrecked hundreds of lives. Why?”

Recommended

Which Covid vaccine works best as a booster jab?
A man receives his first Covid-19 dose in Surrey
Fact file

Which Covid vaccine works best as a booster jab?

The National Trust: a cultural battleground
Winston Churchill’s former residence Chartwell, near Westerham in Kent
In Focus

The National Trust: a cultural battleground

Should the wait for Covid boosters be cut to five months?
A pop-up vaccination service in Newcastle
Getting to grips with . . .

Should the wait for Covid boosters be cut to five months?

Inside the Booker Prize: arguments, agonies and minor scandals
The contenders for the 2012 Booker Prize, which was won by Hilary Mantel 
Behind the scenes

Inside the Booker Prize: arguments, agonies and minor scandals

Popular articles

Why does the UK have highest Covid case rate in western Europe?
England lockdown lifted
Today’s big question

Why does the UK have highest Covid case rate in western Europe?

The tally of Covid-19 vaccine deaths examined
Boy receiving Covid vaccine
Getting to grips with . . .

The tally of Covid-19 vaccine deaths examined

What is blackfishing?
Shot of Jesy Nelson with her hair in braids
In Depth

What is blackfishing?

The Week Footer Banner