Instant Opinion

‘Donald Trump should be given back his access to social media’

Your digest of analysis and commentary from the British and international press

Donald Trump

1

Ian Burrell in the i newspaper

He’s a puerile bully, but Donald Trump should not be banned from social media forever

on a sledgehammer solution 

“You might think the world has enough problems just now but, sooner or later, Donald Trump should be given back his access to social media,” argues Ian Burrell in the i newspaper. “Yes, it’s been a relief that for the past four-and-a-half months, as the world focuses on vaccine rollouts and increased tension in the Middle East, ‘The Donald’ has been unable to contribute to debate with his usual torrent of incendiary online posts,” he writes. “But arbitrary and permanent censorship is not the way to go – it’s the kind of sledgehammer solution that would appeal to an authoritarian, loudmouthed bully like the 45th president.” “Trump is Potus no longer, and he should not be granted the special status of a deposed king in exile.” Burrell concludes: “In due course, he should be reinstated on social media and if he breaks the rules he should be penalised again. Just like a grounded child.”

2

Alex Niven in The Guardian

Starmer’s pitiful pitch to England’s north-east is a recipe for more disasters

on Labour hinterlands

The circumstances behind Labour’s “extraordinary” defeat in Hartlepool “tell us much about the party under [Keir] Starmer,” says Alex Niven in The Guardian. “The Labour leadership seems to imagine ‘red wall’ seats such as Hartlepool as dim hinterlands full of patriotic, socially conservative, working-class voters – the polar opposite of a caricatured ‘metropolitan elite',” he writes. “According to this reading, the task of rebuilding support in these areas is a simple case of airlifting Saint George flags into town during election campaigns and repeating hollow, patronising cliches about ‘trust’ and ‘competence’. But people in the north-east are like people everywhere else: intelligent enough to want more than mere competence and diverse enough that they deserve to be treated with nuance,” he continues. “Neither were apparent in the ‘pints and flags’ pitch that Labour made to the Hartlepool electorate.”

3

Libby Purves in The Times

Moral superiority is the curse of our times

on virtuousness 

“As a person, family, institution or even a nation it is fatally easy to think of yourself as on the side of the angels. Badness is what the other lot do,” writes Libby Purves in The Times. “We make mistakes but innocently; we mean well, our tiny faults are loveable.” It’s easy to see how this “blindness” to our own fallibility occurs: “the blazing goodness of your charity or your cause blots out the possibility that you are also doing bad things. The principle applies right down to the level of individual absurdity: like David Cameron convinced that his lobbying as an employee and shareholder of Greensill Capital was ‘absolutely in the interests of the public good’,” Purves continues. “This ability to believe in your own virtue, provided you utter the approved slogans, is neither logical nor helpful but it’s a key marker of the modern world.”

4

Poppy Coburn in UnHerd

How infographic activism took over social media

on pre-packaged opinions

“If Instagram could speak its algorithms would say: ‘you are important, and you could – yes, you! – solve the crisis in the Middle East,” writes Poppy Coburn in UnHerd. The social media platform can provide you with a “myriad of ready-made hot takes to select from at your leisure”. Anyone with a social media presence is likely to have come across an ‘infographic’ in recent years: “these perfectly-sharable little images are jam-packed with dubiously sourced factoids addressing the hot-button issues of the current moment.” The demand for these infographics is “enormous” and not necessarily a case of “slacktivism”. But an over-reliance on these “quippy cartoon strawmen on pastel backgrounds” demonstrates “the difficulty people have with maintaining attention to complex issues”. And it presents a greater problem still, argues Coburn, Instead of “on-the-ground journalistic coverage setting the agenda for political debate, legacy media institutions now often find themselves playing catch-up with dubious narratives already formed on social media”.

5

Misha Glenny in the Financial Times

The Colonial Pipeline cyber attack is a warning of worse to come

on ransomware

“The cyber attack on Colonial Pipeline, which transports 45 per cent of oil consumed on the east coast of the US, should be the event that finally wakes everyone up,” writes Misha Glenny in the Financial Times. If the consequences of the attack  “don’t alert people to the seriousness of the rapidly-spreading plague of ransomware, then it is hard to conceive of what will”, he writes. “The proliferation of devices and innovative software has collided with inadequate cybersecurity regimes, lowering the barriers to entry for criminal activity so that they scarcely exist.” If a “two-bit outfit” like DarkSide, the criminal organisation thought to be behind the Colonial Pipeline cyber-attack, can halt the flow of oil into half the US “just imagine what a state actor with real resources is capable of”. 

Recommended

Donald Trump hits campaign trail to demand Republican loyalty
Donald Trump
In Brief

Donald Trump hits campaign trail to demand Republican loyalty

Did government Covid policies help the Indian variant spread?
Injecting vaccine into arm
Expert’s view

Did government Covid policies help the Indian variant spread?

‘Ecstasy and Agony’
Today's newspaper front pages
Today’s newspapers

‘Ecstasy and Agony’

Should ‘empire’ be dropped from the UK’s honour titles?
161007_queen_elizabeth.jpg
Why we’re talking about . . .

Should ‘empire’ be dropped from the UK’s honour titles?

Popular articles

The decline and fall of Europe’s centre-left
Tony Blair and Gerhard Schröder
In Focus

The decline and fall of Europe’s centre-left

Sex doll’s husband considers dating humans
A sex doll
Tall Tales

Sex doll’s husband considers dating humans

Quiz of The Week
Boris Johnson receives his second dose of the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine
Quizzes and puzzles

Quiz of The Week