Instant Opinion

‘Teenagers shouldn’t have to decide if they’re public figures or jesters’

Your digest of analysis and commentary from the British and international press


Andrew Lilico in The Telegraph

Since when did teenagers become representatives of society?

on past indiscretions

“In the past few days we have seen several cases of ‘offence archaeology’,” writes Andrew Lilico in The Telegraph. That’s when “malicious” people dig up things that were said decades ago on Twitter when now-public figures were teenagers. “Most commentary has focused on the unfairness of judging an adult by their misdeeds as a teenager. And of course that is the worst aspect of this,” writes Lilico. But we should also “object to judging everything a private person does by the standards a public figure should aspire to”. Indeed, “what it would be deeply improper for Keir Starmer to do can be fine for a teenager to do, just as what would be deeply improper for Boris Johnson to do can be fine for a jester to do,” Lilico writes. And “a teenager should not have to decide, now, that they want either to become one of society’s representatives or a jester in future, and set their path forevermore, by their comments today.”


Aisha Dodwell in The Guardian

The big question about British foreign aid is always missed: what is it supporting?

on reframing aid

While the debate over what percentage of national income should be spent on overseas aid threatens to “rumble on”, we should note “disproportionate attention” has been given to the “narrow question of how much is spent” rather than the key questions “what aid is being spent on and, crucially, why we spend it at all,” says Aisha Dodwell in The Guardian. “When spent well, aid can transform lives and, in humanitarian crises, quite literally save lives,” she writes. But “the full potential of aid spending has not always been realised”. “If aid is to meaningfully tackle poverty, then we need to reframe its very purpose”, she continues. “It can’t just be about charity, and shouldn’t be about self-interest”. Instead, aid should be “part of a broader commitment to dismantling the power structures that maintain global poverty and inequality.”


Sean O’Grady in The Independent

No one actually cares what students think – we should just ignore them

on student politics

“Maybe the country is missing a few things about the molten magma of rage that has erupted” after students at Magdalen College, Oxford, decided to take down a picture of the Queen, writes Sean O’Grady in The Independent. Firstly, these Magdalenites are graduate students, and so much more likely to be from abroad – they are therefore probably “less inclined to be Her Majesty’s liege men and women than, say, Oliver Dowden or Gavin Williamson,” writes O’Grady. We’d do well to remember “that this is the sort of fun and games students of all kinds get up to, and much the best policy is to generally ignore it.” When “I ran the Junior Common Room at an Oxford college and we were always trying to get attacked by the national media,” he writes. “We once sent an impertinent letter to The Sun…pompously informing him that we’d cancelled our subscription because of their coverage of the miners’ strike, adds O’Grady. “We got nothing back, not even a made-up quote from a Page 3 girl about how we’d ‘failed to understand the treachery of Arthur Scargill and the enemy within’.” “But, from Fleet Street to Downing Street to Buenos Aires, no one gave a rat’s sh*t about what we thought. Which is as it should be.”


The Times editorial board

The Times view on travel restrictions: Holidays on Hold

on mixed messaging

“From the onset of the pandemic, the public has understood the need for restrictions on liberty to stop the spread of infection,” says The Times. The public has given the government their support on this, and what they “reasonably expect in return is clarity about the rules”, says the paper. “Yet on the matter of overseas travel, the government has conveyed muddle.” “Boris Johnson needs to get control of the messaging” on travel restrictions – indeed, “almost as soon as the traffic light system was announced, ministers contradicted each other on what it meant.” Ultimately, if the government “genuinely wants people to stay in Britain for the duration of the crisis, it should say so plainly and acknowledge the costs of this course for national morale and the travel industry,” says the paper. “Procrastination and ambiguity are merely spreading bewilderment.”


John Litchfield on UnHerd

Why Emmanuel Macron needed that slap

on political attacks

“As slaps go, it was a rather feeble one, more of swipe than a slap”, writes John Litchfield on UnHerd. “The young man who struck President Emmanuel Macron in the Rhône valley yesterday lacked conviction. It was as if he said to himself: ‘Am I really going to change my life by hitting the President in front of the TV cameras’,” writes Lichfield. Will yesterday’s slap prove to be “prophetic”? asks Lichfield. “Will this act of lèse majesté go down as a humiliation which pre-figured Macron’s defeat in the presidential election next year?” “I doubt it," he writes. “Macron may or may not be defeated but yesterday’s event is playing, so far, in the President’s favour.” Opposition politicians on both the far-right and left “have been building up a hysterical portrait of a wickedly arrogant president, who has been more destructive than any previous French leader,” he writes. The attack may encourage the opposition to calm their “inflammatory rhetoric” for a while, but for now the attack, politically at least, “hasn’t done the president any harm.”


Raab, Rayner and the ‘approving wink’
Dominic Raab
Why we’re talking about . . .

Raab, Rayner and the ‘approving wink’

Partygate inquiry kicks off: Westminster’s Jerry Springer?
Labour grandee Harriet Harman
Talking point

Partygate inquiry kicks off: Westminster’s Jerry Springer?

The pros and cons of streaming trials online
Lady Justice on top of Old Bailey the Central Criminal Court of England and Wales
Pros and cons

The pros and cons of streaming trials online

‘Breakthrough on abortion rights could be there if Biden reaches for it’
Joe Biden walking
Instant Opinion

‘Breakthrough on abortion rights could be there if Biden reaches for it’

Popular articles

Are we heading for World War Three?
Ukrainian soldiers patrol on the frontline in Zolote, Ukraine
In Depth

Are we heading for World War Three?

When will paper £20 and £50 notes expire?
Paper banknotes
Business Briefing

When will paper £20 and £50 notes expire?

What happened to Zara Aleena?
Zara Aleena
In Brief

What happened to Zara Aleena?

The Week Footer Banner