Instant Opinion

‘America’s new vision is of pan-Western solidarity, not Brexit Britain’

Your digest of analysis and commentary from the British and international press

1

Janan Ganesh in the Financial Times

Britain can expect few favours from Biden

on the special relationship

“It is hard to convey the desire in an Asia-facing US for zero distractions in the rest of the world,” writes Janan Ganesh in the Financial Times. “The waiving of sanctions over the Nord Stream 2 pipeline, the exit from Afghanistan, the presidential talks with Vladimir Putin, all suggest a nation set on minimising non-Chinese sources of stress,” he writes. “To that end, Biden views the EU (a “strong and vibrant entity”) as a guarantor of European cohesion, like all pre-Trump presidents.” For the new president “there is no bitterness or even much discussion any more of Britain’s decision to leave it. But nor is there the slightest qualm about engaging with the continent through Berlin or Paris, if London renders itself peripheral or eccentric.” Indeed, “for all the pomp of the new ‘Atlantic Charter’, Britain and America will keep returning to this crux. The point of Brexit is the flexibility to scour the world for commercial and diplomatic openings. But the new US vision is one of pan-western solidarity: against economic undercutting, against the raw weight of China.”

2

Hugo Rifkind in The Times

Strong views are no substitute for news

on anti-woke journalism 

“The slight oddity with GB News,” writes Hugo Rifkind in The Times, is that “we will always already know” its views. “Andrew Neil made a point of telling us, the moment the channel went live. GB News is anti-woke. It is against the ‘metropolitan mind-set’, against ‘identity politics’ and against ‘cancel culture'. It is, come what may, ‘proud to be British’. It is a channel with views, and it will never keep them hidden. This, literally, is the point.” It seems “absurd to suggest that GB News is tilting against ‘the wasteland to nowhere that is identity politics’ (as Neil has) when it is in fact proudly building a citadel on its rightmost flank.” “All the same,” writes Rifkind, “I cannot pretend to be anything other than edgy at the further, unabashed degradation of the idea that news is one thing, opinion is another, and that a journalist’s foremost job is to comprehend the difference. Yes, we fail. Perhaps always. Perhaps every day. But God, at least we should try.”

3

Jonathan Liew in the New Statesman

England’s players have won the nation over – on and off the pitch

on footballers coming home

“First came the boos. This much, at least, could have been predicted,” writes Jonathan Liew in the New Statesman. Just seconds before England’s first home game at a major men’s tournament since 1996, “Wembley Stadium shook to the sound of fans barracking their own team” as they took the knee ahead of their first European Championship match, Liew writes. “At which point, something rather uplifting occurred. Applause broke out: a little at first, and then a little louder. Then some shouting and cheering. Finally, English football’s silent majority had spoken,” writes Liew. “In a sense, this too was hardly surprising. The idea of the English footballing public as a homogeneous rump of unreconstructed racists may be a convenient narrative for both sides of the political divide. But the truth is a little more complex.” And perhaps there’s another reason support broke out among the fans, too: “We like our footballers now. Or at least, we like these footballers: courageous, principled young men who for all their wealth and fame are far more engaged with the world and their communities than many of their predecessors.”

4

Zoe Williams in The Guardian

With the extension of lockdown, Labour has one more chance to get match-ready

on building support 

“Keir Starmer would probably never have appeared at Glastonbury to hear 20,000 people sing his name,” writes Zoe Williams in The Guardian. But because of ongoing coronavirus restrictions, “he does feel keenly the absence of the walkabout, being able to meet voters” and, in doing so, “become flesh-and-blood to them” rather than the rather “abstract” figure he now appears to be. Indeed, across “an increasingly fractured Labour party, there is one point of agreement: that the leader has to find a way to say who he is, to become three-dimensional to, and definable by, the electorate.” According to Williams, Starmer “won’t coalesce as a politician until he says something that costs him: something a Conservative couldn’t say, something that will win him enemies as well as friends”.

5

Ed West in UnHerd

Why didn’t we shut the border with India sooner?

on misguided ties

“Boris [Johnson] is by nature a libertarian, but what that means during a pandemic is libertarianism in the sky, and authoritarianism on the ground; you either have freedom between countries, or freedom within them,” writes Ed West in UnHerd. “Johnson once again chose the former, because it’s the easier thing to do; the rest of us are paying the price. The Government apparently delayed red-listing India because it didn’t want to ‘offend’ [Narendra] Modi,” writes West, but in doing so “we have sacrificed our chance to return to normal life” – and all because of “a strain of Tory Commonwealth nostalgia who believe that we have more in common with India than with Germany and France because we both play cricket and have a common history”, he argues. 

Recommended

‘Hissy fits’ and blatant bullying: Sajid Javid vs. the GPs
Sajid Javid
In Brief

‘Hissy fits’ and blatant bullying: Sajid Javid vs. the GPs

The energy price cap examined
Gas hob flame
Getting to grips with . . .

The energy price cap examined

Nightclubs facing boycott over ‘needle spiking’
Nightclub dancefloor
In Depth

Nightclubs facing boycott over ‘needle spiking’

‘Educated girls can heal economies and heal the planet’
Afghan girls selling water at Nadir Khan hilltop in Kabul
Instant Opinion

‘Educated girls can heal economies and heal the planet’

Popular articles

Why does the UK have highest Covid case rate in western Europe?
England lockdown lifted
Today’s big question

Why does the UK have highest Covid case rate in western Europe?

The tally of Covid-19 vaccine deaths examined
Boy receiving Covid vaccine
Getting to grips with . . .

The tally of Covid-19 vaccine deaths examined

Insulate Britain: what do they want?
Insulate Britain protesters
Profile

Insulate Britain: what do they want?

The Week Footer Banner