Instant Opinion

‘It’s perverse to claim ‘white privilege’ discourse is holding back working class boys’

Your digest of analysis and commentary from the British and international press

1

James Bloodsworth on CapX

Working-class white children are struggling – but it’s nothing to do with ‘white privilege’

on an educational straw man

“I grew up in something approximating a ‘white working-class’ home”, writes James Bloodsworth on CapX. “We just saw ourselves as ‘normal’, though we were keenly aware of the financial distinctions which placed some of our middle class neighbours slightly above us.” Despite having not “quite joined the middle class”, Bloodsworth says he has “done better than would normally be expected of someone from my background”. But in order to get there, he “had to first penetrate a thousand subtle and not so subtle class barriers”. The publication of a Commons Education Select Committee report yesterday has seen “the voguish term” white privilege blamed for why white working-class children are “falling behind”. But “it’s perverse to claim that ‘white privilege’ discourse is holding back working-class boys” as “white working-class children have been falling behind for years”. “Attempts to blame ‘white privilege’ discourse for the struggles of working-class kids are a flagrant attempt to stoke the flames of the culture war”, Bloodsworth adds. “It may generate headlines, but it will do little to help kids who grew up like I did.”

2

Timothy Garton Ash in The Guardian

Five years on from the Brexit referendum, the result is clear: both unions are losing

on collateral damage

“Five years after the fateful referendum on 23 June 2016, what is the current balance sheet of Brexit?” asks Timothy Garton Ash in The Guardian. “Answer: two weakened unions, the British and the European, and bad-tempered relations between them. Lose. Lose. Lose.” While “the weakening of the British union is obvious”, many of “the negative economic consequences of Brexit have been hidden by the impact of the pandemic”. Meanwhile, “it is less immediately obvious that the European Union has been weakened”, but “levels of Euroscepticism are alarmingly high in core member states”. “These views are not a result of Brexit”, Garton Ash says, but “they are a product of concerns similar to those that drove many Brits towards Brexit”. “In the long run, we must work towards a Britain where a clear majority sees the point of being in the EU”, he adds. “And an EU that is doing so well that even the sceptical, cussed English want to rejoin it.”

3

Daniel Finkelstein in The Times

There is no point to the Liberal Democrats

on powerless politics

“Last week the Liberal Democrats, against all the odds, achieved a stunning by-election victory in Chesham & Amersham”, writes Daniel Finkelstein in The Times. But while “the Conservative Party should take its defeat seriously… the Liberal Democrats should be altogether more sceptical of the significance of their victory”. “Their party was at a dead end the day before the by-election, and it was at a dead end the day after it, too,” he says. “Since its collapse at the 2015 general election it has been a waste of the copious amount of time and energy that so many intelligent, capable people have expended upon it.” The party’s problem, he adds, is that “they don’t stand for anything, they don’t stand for anybody, they can’t win and even if they could it would be utterly pointless”. “The party doesn’t know who it is for, preferring to be seen as the party of everybody while in reality being the party of almost nobody.” As it stands, “they are splitting the progressive vote and dissipating progressive energy”, he adds. “Perhaps that is none of my business, but nevertheless, and with genuine respect, I really think that they ought to stop.”

4

Andrew Lilico in The Telegraph

Remainers who dismiss our new trade agreements as worthless don’t understand how trade works

on economic illiteracy

“When negotiations with the EU over a post-Brexit free trade agreement became tense, the media filled with stories of how having no free trade agreement with the EU would create huge turmoil and sustained recession”, writes Andrew Lilico in The Telegraph. “Yet when the UK’s trade agreements with Japan or Australia were announced... we are told that such agreements are worth at best 0.01-0.1% of GDP.” Noting that “the EU is less than half our trade”, he continues that “the notion that a trade deal with the EU is worth 100 or 1,000 times as much as a deal with anyone or everyone else… sounds like it has to be wrong”, adding: “And that’s because it is.” As “most of our trade is not with the EU... most of the value trading provides to our economy is not with the EU”, meaning the trade deals being signed “are all very much worth having, and very valuable to our economy”. “Don’t let misleading partial economic analyses tell you otherwise.”

5

Drew Goins in The Washington Post

Sports used to lead social progress. Carl Nassib shows it’s now the other way around

on sexual diversity

“To listen to the video that Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Carl Nassib posted Monday night on his Instagram, you’d certainly think” sports was making progress on sexual diversity, writes Drew Goins in The Washington Post. “What’s up, people?”, he said in the video posted to social media, “I’m at my house here in West Chester, Pa. I just wanna take a quick moment to say that I’m gay”. However,“this gimme field goal of a coming out belies a wild fact: Nassib is the first active NFL player – ever – to come out as gay”. “If his historic announcement was casual, it’s not because football changed”, Goines says, “it’s because the world did”. “Once upon a time, sporting society helped lead the way in racial integration”, he adds. “Now, when it comes to sexuality, it’s the rest of society dragging sports along with it.”

Recommended

‘The UK has become culturally work-shy’
Waiter working in a London cafe
Instant Opinion

‘The UK has become culturally work-shy’

What is on the agenda for Boris Johnson’s cabinet ‘away day’?
Boris Johnson during the Conservative Party conference in Manchester
Behind the scenes

What is on the agenda for Boris Johnson’s cabinet ‘away day’?

Who’s to blame for UK’s looming Christmas crisis?
A man dressed as Santa Claus walks through Manchester city centre
Today’s big question

Who’s to blame for UK’s looming Christmas crisis?

‘Queen’s green anger’
Today's newspaper front pages
Today’s newspapers

‘Queen’s green anger’

Popular articles

Why a ‘super-cold’ is spreading
flu_sneeze.jpg
Getting to grips with . . .

Why a ‘super-cold’ is spreading

Former nurse says NHS made her ‘fart against her will’
A nurse
Tall Tales

Former nurse says NHS made her ‘fart against her will’

The Queen’s biggest public gaffes
Queen with Duchess of Cornwall and Elin Jones
In Depth

The Queen’s biggest public gaffes

The Week Footer Banner