In Depth

Alice Sebold, Lucky and the man wrongfully convicted of her rape

Anthony Broadwater cried ‘tears of joy and relief’ after being exonerated following 16 years in prison

Bestselling US author Alice Sebold has apologised for her part in the wrongful conviction of a man exonerated last week of raping her 40 years ago.

Anthony Broadwater, who spent 16 years in prison, was jailed in 1982 after he was found guilty of raping Sebold when she was a first-year student at Syracuse University the previous year.

Sebold, 58, is best known for her 1999 memoir Lucky, which details her experience of being raped by a stranger, and the 2002 novel The Lovely Bones, an award-winning supernatural thriller about a teenage girl who is raped and murdered.

Lucky sold more than a million copies and “kicked off her career as an author”, said Variety. The Lovely Bones sold ten million copies and was adapted into an Oscar-nominated film directed by Peter Jackson and starring Saoirse Ronan.

Shoddy conviction

In Sebold’s memoir, she details spotting a black man who she believes is her rapist months after the attack. “He was smiling as he approached. He recognised me. It was a stroll in the park to him; he had met an acquaintance on the street,” she wrote.

Sebold said that she went to police, where an officer suggested that “it must have been Broadwater, who had supposedly been seen in the area”, the Los Angeles Times reported.

Sebold initially failed to identify Broadwater in a police lineup, but later identified him in court.  

In a hearing on 22 November, William J. Fitzpatrick, the district attorney of Onondaga County, New York State, noted that such witness identifications of strangers are often unreliable, particularly when they cross racial lines – as was the case for Sebold, a white woman, and Broadwater, a black man.

Broadwater, who was 20 years old at the time of his imprisonment, was convicted largely based on two pieces of evidence: Sebold identifying him as the perpetrator, and microscopic hair analysis which tied him to the crime. Such analysis “is now considered junk science by the US Department of Justice”, said the Associated Press (AP).

After finishing his prison term in 1999, Broadwater, now 61, remained on New York’s sex offender registry and faced years of shame and isolation as a result. 

Even after starting a relationship with a woman who believed in his innocence, the stigma of Broadwater’s conviction put him off ever having children. He told AP that the conviction “blighted his job prospects and his relationships with friends and family members”. 

Film adaptation leads to exoneration 

In 2019, a film adaptation of Lucky was announced, with 13 Reasons Why’s Karen Moncrieff on board to write and direct. Two years later, in May 2021, Variety revealed that Victoria Pedretti, the star of major Netflix hit You, had been chosen to play the role of Sebold. 

However, plans for the movie were dropped after it lost its financing and executive producer Timothy Mucciante began to question Sebold’s memoir. “I started having some doubts, not about the story that Alice told about her assault, which was tragic, but the second part of her book about the trial, which didn’t hang together,” he told The New York Times

After dropping out of the project, Mucciante hired a private investigator to look into the evidence against Broadwater. He realised that it didn’t stand up and brought the results to a lawyer. “That lawyer, David Hammond, wound up representing Broadwater successfully in court,” the Los Angeles Times said. 

Broadwater had maintained his innocence throughout and on 22 November, a state judge, his lawyers and the district attorney agreed that his case had been “woefully flawed”, The New York Times reported.

Upon hearing the news that his conviction had been overturned, Broadwater cried “tears of joy and relief”, he told the AP. 

“I’m not going to sully these proceedings by saying, ‘I’m sorry,’” Fitzpatrick, the district attorney, said in court. “That doesn’t cut it. This should never have happened.”

Sebold’s apology

Broadwater told The New York Times last week that he was hoping and praying for an apology from Sebold. “I sympathise with her,” he added. “But she was wrong.”

Just over a week later, in a statement posted on the blogging platform Medium, the author has acknowledged the role she “unwittingly played within a system that sent an innocent man to jail”.

“My goal in 1982 was justice – not to perpetuate injustice,” she wrote. “And certainly not to forever, and irreparably, alter a young man’s life by the very crime that had altered mine.”

On Tuesday, in a statement shared on the business-to-business platform Publishers Lunch, Simon & Schuster and its imprint Scribner announced that they would stop publishing Lucky in all formats “following the recent exoneration of Anthony Broadwater, and in consultation with the author”.

Recommended

Religious tolerance, trans treatment and police misogyny
The star of David
Podcast

Religious tolerance, trans treatment and police misogyny

What is a ‘trigger warning’ and why are they controversial?
J.K. Rowling reading from Harry Potter
Getting to grips with . . .

What is a ‘trigger warning’ and why are they controversial?

Celebrity vaccine wars over misinformation
Joe Rogan and Neil Young
Why we’re talking about . . .

Celebrity vaccine wars over misinformation

Quiz of The Week: 22 - 28 January
Members of the Kiev Territorial Defence take part in drills
Quizzes and puzzles

Quiz of The Week: 22 - 28 January

Popular articles

Are we heading for a snap general election?
Jacob Rees-Mogg
Today’s big question

Are we heading for a snap general election?

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?
Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik
In Depth

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?

Why is New Zealand shutting its borders again?
Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern adjusts her face mask following a press conference
In Depth

Why is New Zealand shutting its borders again?

The Week Footer Banner