Between the lines

The Pandora Papers: will the war on tax dodgers ever end?

Leaks are clearly discouraging tax avoiders, but more needs to be done to fight financial crime

There was a “depressing familiarity” about the Pandora Papers, said Brooke Harrington in The New York Times. The contents of almost 12 million leaked financial records, published by an international consortium of journalists last week, exposed “legalised corruption” in the offshore finance industry “on an almost unimaginably vast scale”.

But so, too, did the Panama Papers and the Paradise Papers before them – leading to a sense that nothing ever changes. Actually, though, things are changing. It is clear that these leaks are discouraging elites from using offshore financial services. There may be no real chance of being prosecuted, but the risk of reputational damage is large: just ask Andrej Babiš, the Czech PM whose party lost a general election last week, days after the papers revealed that he had used offshore shell companies to secretly buy property on the French Riviera.

Tax avoidance, personal or corporate, is “increasingly regarded as immoral and unpatriotic”. And thanks to modern technology, whistleblowing is safer and easier than ever: five years after the Panama Papers, no one knows who was responsible. The leaks are going to keep coming.

Days after the Pandora Papers were released, the Irish government finally abandoned its 12.5% corporate tax rate, said The Irish Times – “a once-untouchable totem of Irish economic policy”. There was a “certain symmetry to the timing”. Just as people are sick of the rich hiding their wealth from the authorities, so public tolerance of vastly wealthy firms using “lopsided national tax regimes” to avoid paying tax where they do business “has never been lower”.

Owing to this new intolerance, 136 nations, including the entire G20, have agreed to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s global tax reform plan, said Richard Partington in The Guardian. Backed enthusiastically by the UK and, crucially, President Biden, this aims to set a minimum world corporate tax rate of 15%.

Still, the UK remains a major player in the world of offshore finance, said Matthew Shillito on The Conversation. And it must do much more to reform the sector. In 2016, after the Panama Papers, David Cameron pushed for a beneficial ownership register that would force UK companies to reveal the people who ultimately benefit from its assets. “Five years later, we are no further forward.”

In 2018, a draft bill was published that would have forced “overseas entities” buying UK property to disclose their beneficiaries; but that too has stalled. The Government talks a good game about fighting financial crime – but ultimately, “lack of action speaks louder than words”.

Recommended

Top Gun: Maverick - Tom Cruise makes a thrilling return
Tom Cruise in Top Gun: Maverick
In Review

Top Gun: Maverick - Tom Cruise makes a thrilling return

Is Joe Biden taking a tougher stance on Taiwan?
President Joe Biden in meeting
In Brief

Is Joe Biden taking a tougher stance on Taiwan?

What next for Russia’s high-profile defectors?
Vladimir Putin during a meeting of he Summit of Collective Security Treaty Organisation
In Depth

What next for Russia’s high-profile defectors?

The Time Traveler’s Wife: a ‘problematic’ adaptation of the hit novel
Theo James and Rose Leslie
In Review

The Time Traveler’s Wife: a ‘problematic’ adaptation of the hit novel

Popular articles

Is Russian President Vladimir Putin seriously ill?
Vladimir Putin
Why we’re talking about . . .

Is Russian President Vladimir Putin seriously ill?

Are assassins trying to kill Putin?
Vladimir Putin hosting a meeting in the Kremlin via video link
Behind the scenes

Are assassins trying to kill Putin?

What could happen if China invaded Taiwan?
Chinese troops on mobile rocket launchers during a parade in Beijing
Fact file

What could happen if China invaded Taiwan?

The Week Footer Banner