Pros and cons

The pros and cons of local lockdowns

Targeted approach to restrictions considered by ministers as Indian variant cases rise

A return to local lockdowns in England has not been ruled out by the government as it considers how to stop the spread of the new Indian coronavirus variant.

More than 2,300 cases of the B16172 mutation, which is believed to be more transmissible than previous incarnations, have been identified across at least 86 local authorities. Bolton and Blackburn with Darwen, in the north-west of England, have been hit the hardest.

Environment Secretary George Eustice told Sky News this morning that imposing local restrictions “would be an option” for areas that are still struggling after lockdown is due to be lifted on 21 June.

Pros

Avoiding further national restrictions

Local lockdowns are seen “as an alternative to delaying the full nationwide lifting of coronavirus measures”, says Esther Webber at Politico. This would benefit the majority of the country, who would be able to return to normality on time.

“Officials familiar with [Boris] Johnson’s thinking say he is reluctant to keep the whole country in a longer period of restrictions,” she says. One Cabinet minister told Webber: “The PM will do what he can to keep to the national timeframe of the 21st. I expect local lockdowns will be more likely.”

Targeting hotspots

The government’s interactive coronavirus map shows how cases are dispersed across the country. Many areas have fewer than three cases, while one neighbourhood in Bolton has 92 cases and a rolling infection rate of more than 1,000.

As the Institute for Government says, “the aim of a local lockdown is to control the spread of the coronavirus pandemic by containing it within a particular area and so avoid re-imposing social distancing restrictions across the whole of the country”.

Flexibility

Scotland is still operating five “protection levels” depending on where people live. While much of the country has now moved to level one or two, Glasgow remains in level three as infections have been rising in the city. The Scottish government also takes into account data on areas such as hospital demand, unlinked cases, vaccine uptake and population density.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has said the system “enables us to respond quickly and flexibly as required, particularly in areas where we are concerned about the rate at which the virus is spreading”.

Cons

Doubts over effectiveness

Professor James Naismith, from the University of Oxford, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme that local lockdowns would not work and the new Indian variant should be viewed as a national problem that “will get everywhere”.

Indeed, analysis by The Guardian, published in October, nine weeks after large swathes of northern England were put into lockdown, found the infection rate at least doubled in 11 out of 16 cities and towns affected. At the time, Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham accused the government of trying to stem the virus “on the cheap” without offering sufficient financial support for the region.

Confusion over rules

Another reason cited by scientists, MPs and local leaders for the increase in infections last year was that rules for the “growing patchwork of local measures” were “unclear”, said The Guardian.

By November, the outbreak was still growing and the government introduced the second national lockdown followed by a tier system of different local restrictions. “We know they weren’t enough to contain the spread as they too were replaced with lockdown,” says Channel 4’s FactCheck. The government blamed the new Kent variant for the third lockdown in January, but FactCheck says “it remains an open question as to whether we can declare the tiered system a success”.

‘Difficult and divisive’

Last year, Middlesbrough mayor Andy Preston spoke out against what he called a “monstrous” lack of communication from Westminster with local areas, calling for a better way to tackle Covid while also preserving local jobs and mental health.

Shadow housing secretary Lucy Powell today said Labour was “very reluctant and wary to go down the road of local lockdowns”. Targeted restrictions became “incredibly difficult and divisive” for the areas affected last year and “poor old Bolton and Blackburn have really been at the forefront of this”, she told Sky News.

Recommended

Are we heading for a snap general election?
Jacob Rees-Mogg
Today’s big question

Are we heading for a snap general election?

‘The government is still betraying disabled people on Covid’
A wheelchair user on a rainy pavement
Instant Opinion

‘The government is still betraying disabled people on Covid’

Partygate vs. Cash for Honours: the Boris and Blair rows compared
Tony Blair
In Depth

Partygate vs. Cash for Honours: the Boris and Blair rows compared

Where did the term snowflake come from?
Snowflake
Between the lines

Where did the term snowflake come from?

Popular articles

What would a Russian ‘lightning war’ against Ukraine look like?
Members of the Kiev territorial defence forces take part in drills outside Kiev, Ukraine
Getting to grips with . . .

What would a Russian ‘lightning war’ against Ukraine look like?

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?
Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik
In Depth

Is Bosnia on the brink of another civil war?

Why is New Zealand shutting its borders again?
Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern adjusts her face mask following a press conference
In Depth

Why is New Zealand shutting its borders again?

The Week Footer Banner