In Depth

The definition of genocide

Turkey’s military operations against Kurdish positions in Syria has reopened debate about nature of ethnic cleansing

Governments and humanitarian groups are adding their voices to the growing criticism of Turkey’s incursion into Kurdish territory in Syria, amid questions over Ankara’s end goal.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan says that the threat posed by the decades-long Kurdish insurgency within his country’s borders gives Ankara the “right to eliminate” the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK - a militant and political organisation that Turkey, the US and the EU has designated a terrorist group.

But not everyone is convinced by Turkey’s claim that the ongoing military operation is a counterterrorism measure, with some experts alleging that Ankara is attempting to wipe out all Kurds. As violence escalates in Rojava, the Kurdish-controlled autonomous region of northern Syria, Turkish-backed proxies have been accused of summarily executing civilians, raising the “spectre of ethnic bloodletting”, The Guardian reports.

Following the announcement this week that the Syrian army has been deployed to fight alongside Kurdish troops, Mazloum Kobani Abdi, commander of the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), said: “If we have to choose between compromises and the genocide of our people, we will surely choose life for our people.”

However, commentators removed from the conflict have been hesitant to use the word “genocide” to describe the situation unfolding in Rojava.

Indeed, although the meaning of the term is clearly defined by the United Nations (UN), media, politicians and other officials often refuse to use it even in appropriate circumstances.

So why is it such a controversial description?

What is genocide?

The term genocide was first coined by Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin in 1944 in his book Axis Rule in Occupied Europe, says the UN website notes. The word consists of the Greek prefix genos, meaning race or tribe, and the Latin suffix cide, meaning killing.

Genocide was codified in 1948, in the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

According to US broadcaster PBS, the treaty outlines five acts that can constitute genocide if they are done “with the intent to destroy an ethnic, national, racial or religious group”.

These are killing members of the group; causing serious bodily or mental harm; deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about the group’s physical destruction in whole or in part; imposing measures intended to prevent births; and forcibly transferring children.

However, in order to qualify as genocide, the actions “must be done with intent to eliminate an entire group of people”. Without provable intent to do so, a group or individual may instead be charged with “crimes against humanity” or “ethnic cleansing”.

What is wrong with this definition?

According to the BBC, the UN treaty has “come under fire from different sides”, mostly by people “frustrated with the difficulty” of applying the term genocide to specific cases.

Among the main complaints are that the convention excludes targeted political and social - rather than purely ethnic - groups; is limited to direct acts against people; and omits acts against the environment that sustains the victims or their cultural distinctiveness.

However, the most troubling issue is that war crime tribunals have struggled to establish a legal standard for genocidal intent. “Few perpetrators, with the notable exception of the Nazi regime, have left explicit plans detailing their intentions to eradicate groups,” PBS notes.

Yet “genocide is distinguishable from all other crimes by the motivation behind it”, says Alain Destexhe, former secretary-general of Medecins Sans Frontieres, in his book Rwanda and Genocide in the 20th Century. 

The waters are further muddied by incorrect usage of the term, which has fallen victim to “a sort of verbal inflation, in much the same way as happened with the word fascist”, he adds. 

This warning is echoed by Michael Ignatieff, of the Carr Centre for Human Rights Policy at Harvard University, who gives the example of the Trans-Atlantic slave trade. He says that the trade is often called genocide, when in fact “it was a system to exploit, rather than to exterminate the living”.

Why are people hesitant to use the term?

Even in cases where there can be little dispute over the application of the term genocide, some people - particularly world leaders - are often highly reluctant to do so.

The most obvious example is the Armenian Genocide, the mass killing of as many as 1.8 million Armenians by Ottoman Turks between 1915 and 1920. Most historians, citing death marches and mass executions, believe this event to have been a clear-cut case of genocide.

However, History.com notes that the Turkish government has always denied that a genocide took place. “The Armenians were an enemy force, they argue, and their slaughter was a necessary war measure,” the site reports.

Nevertheless, a number of countries have labelled it a genocide, and denial of this classification is officially outlawed in Switzerland, Greece, Cyprus, and Slovakia.

However, Turkey’s importance on the global stage - effectively acting as a bridge between Asia and Europe - has led many other countries to refuse this label for the Armenian massacres.

The US has been wrangling with this issue for decades. “Turkey is seen as a key Nato ally,” says Newsweek, which notes that the European nation was also an important ally against the Soviet Union during the Cold War, and a crucial partner in the fight against the Islamic State in more recent years.

Prior to his election in 2008, Barack Obama said: “Armenian genocide is not an allegation, a personal opinion or a point of view, but rather a widely documented fact supported by an overwhelming body of historical evidence. The facts are undeniable. As president, I will recognise the Armenian genocide.”

But once elected, Obama failed to officially do so, as has his successor.

Recommended

Quiz of The Week: 9 - 15 October
Ambulances outside a hospital during third national lockdown
Quizzes and puzzles

Quiz of The Week: 9 - 15 October

Former nurse says NHS made her ‘fart against her will’
A nurse
Tall Tales

Former nurse says NHS made her ‘fart against her will’

‘Queen’s green anger’
Today's newspaper front pages
Today’s newspapers

‘Queen’s green anger’

The Pandora Papers: will the war on tax dodgers ever end?
Pandora Papers seen on a screen
Between the lines

The Pandora Papers: will the war on tax dodgers ever end?

More on Genocide

Is Ethiopia’s civil war at ‘turning point’ as Tigray rebels retake key cities?
Captured Ethiopian troops arrive at the Mekele Rehabilitation Center
The latest on . . .
14 Jul 2021

Is Ethiopia’s civil war at ‘turning point’ as Tigray rebels retake key cities?

New offensive launched after federal government declares unilateral ceasefire
Why Namibians have rejected ‘insulting’ €1bn German aid offer
German Foreign Minister Heiko Mass announces the deal with the Namibian government
In Depth
4 Jun 2021

Why Namibians have rejected ‘insulting’ €1bn German aid offer

Ethnic leaders are demanding €440bn in reparations for killing of up to 75,000 people
French government ‘enabled foreseeable’ Rwandan genocide
Paul Kagame and Emmanuel Macron in 2018
Getting to grips with . . .
20 Apr 2021

French government ‘enabled foreseeable’ Rwandan genocide

Investigation finds that Paris ‘did nothing to stop’ slaughter of 800,000 people in 1994 mass killings
Can Aung San Suu Kyi reclaim hero status following Myanmar coup?
Aung San Suu Kyi greets supporters in 2015
Today’s big question
2 Feb 2021

Can Aung San Suu Kyi reclaim hero status following Myanmar coup?

The detained civil leader fell from grace over Rohingya crisis but remains face of nation’s pro-democracy movement
Will other nations join US in accusing China of ‘genocide’ against Uighurs?
A protestor joins at a rally outside the White House
In Focus
20 Jan 2021

Will other nations join US in accusing China of ‘genocide’ against Uighurs?

Mike Pompeo warns that the slaughter ‘is on-going’ as MPs vote against amendment to UK-China trade bill
ICC rules out investigation into China’s forced detention of Uighurs
A demonstrator wears a mask showing solidarity with China's Uighur population.
Daily Briefing
16 Dec 2020

ICC rules out investigation into China’s forced detention of Uighurs

Prosecutors’ decision is blow to activists who hoped to use international law to highlight persecution of the Muslim minority
China blanks out map to hide vast network of Uighur detention camps
Camp satellite
In Brief
28 Aug 2020

China blanks out map to hide vast network of Uighur detention camps

More than 250 newly-built compounds across Xinjiang region appear on western map services
Instant Opinion: ‘Trump may lose, but Trumpism will go on’
Donald Trump
In Depth
27 Jul 2020

Instant Opinion: ‘Trump may lose, but Trumpism will go on’

Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Monday 27 July
Instant Opinion: Britain can’t blame its ‘weird politics’ on Russia
Vladimir Putin
In Depth
21 Jul 2020

Instant Opinion: Britain can’t blame its ‘weird politics’ on Russia

Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Tuesday 21 July
Why everyone’s talking about Amal Clooney
Amal Clooney
In Depth
27 Feb 2020

Why everyone’s talking about Amal Clooney

Human rights lawyer is hired by the Maldives in genocide case against Myanmar
UN orders Myanmar to stop Rohingya genocide
Demonstrators call for an end to attacks on Rohingya
In Brief
24 Jan 2020

UN orders Myanmar to stop Rohingya genocide

Landmark ruling ‘obliterates’ any remnants of Aung San Suu Kyi’s international reputation
Myanmar genocide hearings: what you need to know
Aung San Suu Kyi, Myanmar, ICJ
In Depth
10 Dec 2019

Myanmar genocide hearings: what you need to know

Aung San Suu Kyi makes a sensational court appearance in the Hague
Cambodia: Khmer Rouge leaders found guilty of 1970s genocide
Cambodia, Genocide, Khmer Rouge
In Depth
16 Nov 2018

Cambodia: Khmer Rouge leaders found guilty of 1970s genocide

Nuon Chea, 92, and Khieu Samphan, 87, get life sentences for role in killing of up to 30% of Cambodian population
Germany’s other genocide: Namibians sue over colonial slaughter
Namibia Germany
In Brief
30 Aug 2018

Germany’s other genocide: Namibians sue over colonial slaughter

Berlin returns remains of massacred indigenous people but descendants still waiting for apology
France ‘complicit’ in Rwandan genocide
French soldiers did little to stop the bloodshed
In Brief
14 Dec 2017

France ‘complicit’ in Rwandan genocide

Independent report concludes French officials obstructed justice in subsequent investigations
Armenian genocide: why the debate rages, a century on
150420-armenia.jpg
In Depth
20 Apr 2015

Armenian genocide: why the debate rages, a century on

Turkey says there was no systematic attempt to wipe out Armenians, but many scholars disagree
Is Ratko Mladic guilty of war crimes and genocide in Bosnia?
Former Bosnian Serb Military Leader Ratko Mladic
In Depth
19 May 2014

Is Ratko Mladic guilty of war crimes and genocide in Bosnia?

The 'Butcher of Bosnia' begins his defence today, as court considers charges crimes against humanity
UN to send peacekeepers after Central African Republic flare-up
Anti-Balaka fighters show their weapons outside Bangui
In Brief
11 Apr 2014

UN to send peacekeepers after Central African Republic flare-up

At least 30 people, many of them civilians, died in clashes between Christian and Muslim militias this week
The Week Footer Banner