Getting to grips with . . .

The pros and cons of nuclear energy

Scientists say nuclear power is essential to efforts to tackle climate change

Nuclear energy is usually in the news “because something’s gone wrong”. 

Or so says The Economist’s Oliver Morton, but this week the issue is making headlines after Whitehall sources confirmed reports that Downing Street is having second thoughts about a tie-up with China to produce a new generation of nuclear power stations in the UK.

If energy policy does become “another victim” of the “geopolitical recalibration” of relations between the two nations, the UK may struggle to hit its target of achieving non-carbon energy generation by 2050, says The Telegraph.

Yet while this dilemma highlights potential benefits of nuclear energy, critics point to the potential risks of, as Morton puts it, things “going wrong” with the technology - with the threat of nuclear warfare further increasing opposition.

In the UK, attitudes to the energy source have shifted over the decade following the 2011 Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant disaster. In 2012, the first in a series of government surveys to gauge public opinion about nuclear energy and climate change found that 30% of households believed the risks of nuclear outweighed the benefits.

But the latest poll findings, published in May, show that this figure has dropped to 17%, while 38% of the more than 4,000 households quizzed felt that nuclear provides a safe source of energy for the UK. Opinions about nuclear energy’s role in combating climate change have also changed, with 34% in 2012 agreeing that nuclear could help in the UK’s push to tackle the problem, rising to 38% in 2021.

Many experts say that as a reliable energy source with low to zero emissions, nuclear has a vital role to play in helping governments worldwide reach decarbonisation targets. The nuclear issue is by no means clear cut, however, with opponents pointing to various potential disadvantages and hazards. 

Arguments for

Efficiency

Generating energy using nuclear fission requires significantly less fuel - specifically, uranium - than the comparative amount that coal or gas power plants need to produce the equivalent level of power. “You can fuel a nuclear reactor with tonnes of fuel, rather than thousands of tonnes of fuel,” notes Morton in The Economist. And that makes nuclear a competitive energy choice.

Compared with renewables, nuclear is also a highly reliable power source. In the US, nuclear generators have typically operated at more than 90% capacity over the past decade, while wind power capacity has not topped 44%, according to latest US Energy Information Administration data. Nuclear has also consistently operated at higher capacity than hydropower or solar.

Emissions

Once in operation, nuclear power plants produce very low to zero amounts of direct greenhouse gas emissions. According to the World Nuclear Association (WNA), the impact of nuclear energy on carbon emissions is “roughly equivalent to removing one-third of all cars from the world’s roads”. 

After hydropower, nuclear power is the second-largest source of low-carbon energy used to generate electricity, the International Atomic Energy Agency reports. The creation, maintainance and eventual decommissioning of a nuclear plant does contribute to carbon emissions - but the amount is minimal compared with that produced by the running of coal and oil plants.

Public health

Nuclear energy has public health benefits that have already saved vast numbers of lives worldwide, according to a 2013 research paper on the impact of energy sources on mortality rates. The US researchers calculated that nuclear power had prevented an average of 1.84 million deaths between 1971 and 2009 that would have been caused by air pollution resulting from burning fossil fuels. 

By contrast, proponents argue, although exposure to radioactive waste can be lethal, the public’s risk of exposure is very low. The 1986 explosion at Chernobyl claimed the lives of 31 people in the immediate aftermath, but was the disastrous result of “a not very good nuclear plant being run in a terrible way”, says The Economist’s Morton.

And a United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation report published earlier this year found that radiation resulting from the Fukushima nuclear plant meltdown in 2011 had resulted in no documented “adverse health effects” among local residents “that could be directly attributed to radiation exposure from the accident”. 

Arguments against

Threat of nuclear weapons

While an increasing number of governments are embracing nuclear as an energy source, alarm bells may ring when a country “in an unstable part of the world” begins “getting interested in nuclear technology”, says The Economist’s Morton.

Earlier this month, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) confirmed that Iran has begun producing enriched uranium metal. Enriched uranium is used to make fuel for nuclear reactors, but is also used in the production of nuclear weapons. The move by Tehran is a breach of a treaty signed in 2015 with the group of world powers known as the P5+1 - China, France, Russia, the UK, the US and Germany - that had significantly reduced Iran’s stockpile of uranium, and limited the country’s research into and development of nuclear technology. 

Tehran has told the IAEA that Iran’s aim is to develop fuel for a research reactor, but France, Britain and Germany has issued a joint statement expressing “grave concerns'' about the move. 

Cost

Nuclear fission is a much more expensive method of energy production than those involving coal or gas. The cost of running and maintaining nuclear plants is high, while the bills for building the sites are vast. The UK’s Hinkley Point plant was originally expected to cost £18bn and to begin operating in 2017. But EDF, the French energy giant behind the project, announced in January that the final bill is now expected to reach up to £23bn, in part owing to Covid-related delays that mean the plant is unlikely to open until 2026.

However, standardisation of power station designs can help to reduce costs. France has adopted this approach and now derives 70% of the nation’s electricity supply from nuclear power. 

Waste 

Management and disposal of radioactive waste is an ongoing issue in nuclear power production. This waste can be harmful to both humans and the environment, and must be treated and conditioned to turn it into a “safe, stable and manageable form” before being transported and stored, the IAEA explains.

Yet according to Chemical and Engineering News correspondent Mitch Jacoby, “tens of thousands of metric tons of radioactive waste that accumulated from commercial power plants and years of national defence operations continue to age at sites around the globe”. In the US, massive quantities of solid and liquid waste are stored in temporary containers - and while “corrosion experts are doing their part” to protect people from potential harm caused by the hazardous waste, “the stockpile keeps growing”, warns Jacoby. 

Recommended

Quiz of The Week: 9 - 15 October
Ambulances outside a hospital during third national lockdown
Quizzes and puzzles

Quiz of The Week: 9 - 15 October

Former nurse says NHS made her ‘fart against her will’
A nurse
Tall Tales

Former nurse says NHS made her ‘fart against her will’

‘Queen’s green anger’
Today's newspaper front pages
Today’s newspapers

‘Queen’s green anger’

‘Let’s not cage in novelists with bad-faith readings’
Sally Rooney
Instant Opinion

‘Let’s not cage in novelists with bad-faith readings’

More on Nuclear power

China General Nuclear: banned from Britain?
David Cameron and Xi Jinping
In Focus
29 Jul 2021

China General Nuclear: banned from Britain?

The brief ‘golden era’ of Sino-British relations has turned ‘radioactive’
Cuba, friendship and office dogs
Havana streets
Podcast
16 Jul 2021

Cuba, friendship and office dogs

What’s behind the latest Cuban protests? Can dating apps help us make friends? And should we welcome animals at work?
Strict schools, swimming caps and four-day weeks
A 1950s schools scene
Podcast
9 Jul 2021

Strict schools, swimming caps and four-day weeks

Do more rules make for a better education? Is a ban on “Afro caps” a blow to sporting diversity? And will Covid boost calls for a four-day working wee…
Hazardous heat, nuclear fusion and divisive dieting
Controversial weight loss device
Podcast
2 Jul 2021

Hazardous heat, nuclear fusion and divisive dieting

What does a Pakistani city hitting temperatures too hot for the human body tell us about climate change? Could a new nuclear project provide a breakth…
Instant Opinion: Hitachi ‘failed its nuclear test’
Hitachi Wales
In Depth
18 Sep 2020

Instant Opinion: Hitachi ‘failed its nuclear test’

Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Friday 18 September
Can the UK decarbonise without nuclear power?
Hitachi Wales
In Depth
16 Sep 2020

Can the UK decarbonise without nuclear power?

Cancellation of Hitachi nuclear plant in Wales threatens to derail Downing Street’s plans for eliminating CO2
Russia denies radiation increase is linked to its nuclear plants
Chernobyl
In Depth
29 Jun 2020

Russia denies radiation increase is linked to its nuclear plants

Authorities insists no leakages or faults detected following rise in radioactivity levels across northern Europe
Instant Opinion: people ‘believe women lie about rape’
Cyprus rape case
In Depth
8 Jan 2020

Instant Opinion: people ‘believe women lie about rape’

Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Wednesday 8 January
Fukushima: how the nuclear disaster unfolded
Fukushima
In Depth
19 Sep 2019

Fukushima: how the nuclear disaster unfolded

Power company chiefs cleared of negligence charges
The countries with nuclear weapons
wd-nuclear-test-170328.jpg
In Depth
16 Sep 2019

The countries with nuclear weapons

IAEA meets in Vienna amid mounting nuclear tension over Iran
What happened at Chernobyl?
Chernobyl, Ukraine, Nuclear
In Brief
30 May 2019

What happened at Chernobyl?

The story of the world’s worst nuclear disaster is told in critically acclaimed new series
Fukushima evacuation order lifted after eight years
wd-fukushima_-_christopher_furlonggetty_images.jpg
In Brief
11 Apr 2019

Fukushima evacuation order lifted after eight years

Nearly a decade after nuclear reactor suffered meltdown, local residents free to return home
Is Saudi Arabia the next nuclear power?
wd-saudi_flag_-_ozan_koseafpgetty_image.jpg
In Depth
4 Apr 2019

Is Saudi Arabia the next nuclear power?

Gulf state is close to completing its first nuclear reactor, sparking fears among international regulators
UK signals shift from nuclear to renewables
wd-wind_farm_-_christopher_furlonggetty_images.jpg
In Brief
18 Jan 2019

UK signals shift from nuclear to renewables

Business Secretary says ‘economics of the energy market have changed significantly in recent years’
Britain’s nuclear energy future in jeopardy
wd-nuclear_plant_-_christopher_furlonggetty_images.jpg
In Brief
15 Jan 2019

Britain’s nuclear energy future in jeopardy

Hitachi set to suspend work on £16bn reactor, leaving Hinkley Point as the only new UK plant still being built
UK offshore wind power to double by 2030
Britain's largest offshore windfarm off the Great Yarmouth coastline
In Brief
24 Jul 2018

UK offshore wind power to double by 2030

Plummeting renewable costs raise questions about government’s continued support for nuclear energy
Nuclear deal: Iran says Trump sending ‘dangerous message’
Mohammad Javad Zarif
In Brief
23 Apr 2018

Nuclear deal: Iran says Trump sending ‘dangerous message’

Tehran threatens to resume uranium enrichment programme if US quits nuclear deal
Centrica to cut 4,000 jobs and sell UK nuclear holdings
Centrica logo
In Brief
22 Feb 2018

Centrica to cut 4,000 jobs and sell UK nuclear holdings

Beleaguered British Gas owner lost 1.4 million customers last year
Hinkley nuclear deal ‘will hit poorest the hardest’
The Hinkley Point nuclear plant has been beset by delays and controversies
In Brief
23 Nov 2017

Hinkley nuclear deal ‘will hit poorest the hardest’

MPs say ‘blinkered’ policies could lead to £30bn shortfall and spiralling bills
Hinkley Point 'will cost public double the amount it should'
Hinkley Point
In Depth
23 Jun 2017

Hinkley Point 'will cost public double the amount it should'

National Audit Office says nuclear project is 'risky and expensive' and has 'uncertain' economic benefits
US and UK join boycott of UN talks to ban nuclear weapons
170338_nuclearpower.jpg
In Brief
28 Mar 2017

US and UK join boycott of UN talks to ban nuclear weapons

US ambassador says world is too unsafe to outlaw nuclear arms
Why the Doomsday Clock is stuck near 12
150107_clock_0.jpg
In Depth
27 Jan 2016

Why the Doomsday Clock is stuck near 12

Climate change and risk of nuclear war keep symbolic timepiece at three minutes to midnight
South Korea conducts nuclear drill after hack attack
A nuclear reactor in South Korea
In Depth
22 Dec 2014

South Korea conducts nuclear drill after hack attack

Hackers publish blueprints of nuclear power plants online, but South Korea insists it is safe from attack
The Week Footer Banner