Getting to grips with . . .

How the war in Ukraine began and how it might end

From a battlefield stalemate to the descent of a ‘new Iron Curtain’

For Vladimir Putin, the decision to launch an invasion of Ukraine could be his crowning legacy – or the nail in the coffin of his two-decade domination of Russia.

On 24 February, after weeks of warnings from Western intelligence officials, the Russian president ordered a full-scale invasion of his eastern European neighbour. The decision triggered what could become the biggest conflict in Europe since the 1940s.

Here is our guide to how the conflict began, and how the war could eventually end.

Justifying the conflict

Putin has long made clear his belief that Ukraine is an illegitimate state, claiming in an essay published last year that Russians and Ukrainians, along with Belarusians, are one people, belonging to what was historically known as the “All-Russian Nation”.

In the essay, titled On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians, Putin explicitly laid out his argument that Ukraine has no right to call itself an independent nation. “The formation of an ethnically pure Ukrainian state, aggressive towards Russia”, Putin argued, is equivalent to the use of weapons of mass destruction against Russians.

It was based on this logic that Putin justified the 2014 annexation of Crimea, as well as the long-running conflict between Kremlin-backed proxies in the Donbas region. That conflict, fought on Ukrainian soil, claimed 14,000 lives between 2014 and 2022. 

In a speech delivered days before he gave the order for a full-invasion, Putin was internationally condemned for attacking the notion of Ukrainian statehood in an “angry” and “dismissive” speech delivered from the Kremlin.

Putin outlined a “version of Ukraine’s history” in which the territory now controlled by Kyiv “was always part of Russia”, said Associated Press editor-at-large John Daniszewski. Instead, he argued that the land that now comprises Ukraine was stolen from mainland Russia by the Bolsheviks following the formation of the Soviet Union.

But “while that serves his purpose, it is also a fiction” that denies Ukraine’s “own 1,000-year history”, Daniszewski said. World leaders dismissed Putin’s history lesson, but it nonetheless laid the “groundwork for war”, he added.

How the war started

On 21 February, Putin signed a decree recognising the Donetsk People’s Republic and Luhansk People’s Republics, the two self-proclaimed states controlled by pro-Russian separatist forces in Donbas. No other country recognises their independence.

He then deployed Russian troops to the area, arguing that they were “peacekeepers” seeking to avoid a “genocide” of Russias living in the region. 

Ukraine has since “taken Russia to the International Court of Justice for having launched an invasion on the pretext of false claims of genocide perpetrated against the country’s Russian speakers”, The Guardian reported.

What followed was an assault on three fronts, with Russian troops flooding over into Ukrainian territory from annexed Crimea, the separatist-controlled regions in the east and Belarus which shares a border to the north of Ukraine.

Putin justified this attack by arguing that Nato expansion to the east threatened Russian national security, even though Ukraine is not a Nato member and was not likely to join the alliance in the near future. He also claimed to be “demilitarising” and “denazifying” the country, which is led by a democratically elected Jewish president. 

He had intended the invasion to be swift, with troops quickly storming into the capital Kyiv and deposing President Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s government. But his troops were met with stiff resistance from Ukraine’s armed forces, laying the groundwork for the ongoing fighting in several major cities. 

How will the war end? 

Putin’s invasion has not gone to plan, with reports emerging of low morale among soldiers and shortages of basic supplies such as food and fuel. But Russia has seized one major city and appears to be encircling Kyiv, Ukraine’s capital city.

According to the Atlantic Council, there are four likely outcomes at this point in the conflict:

1. Victory for Ukraine

The least likely result, said the think tank, is a “miracle on the Dnipro” in which “Ukraine’s military and civilian resistance overcome the odds and grind Moscow’s advance to a halt”.

Should this happen, it may quickly become “obvious to the Kremlin that Russia will pay an exorbitant price for its adventurism”, meaning Putin could withdraw his troops and Ukraine “remain a sovereign democracy”.

2. Partial victory for Russia

Alternatively, it is possible that the conflict will descend into a “quagmire”, the think tank said.

After weeks or months of fighting, Russia may well “topple Ukraine’s government and install a puppet regime”. But if neither “Ukraine’s armed forces nor its population are ready to surrender”, the battle could evolve into “a broad-based, well-armed, and well-coordinated insurgency against the invaders” that could then drag on for years or even decades.

The Telegraph describes this result as a “pyrrhic victory” for the Kremlin, because “such a development might lead to domestic turmoil in Russia”. It would also create “a vast zone of destabilisation and insecurity”, while “states in the neighbourhood will perceive Russian political control over Ukraine as illegitimate and as a national threat”.

3. Division

The third possible outcome, according to the Atlantic Council, is “a new Iron Curtain”. This would be created if Ukraine “eventually collapses under the weight of the Russian invasion”, creating a divide “running along the borders of the Baltic states in the north through those of Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, and Romania in the south”.

In this scenario, “the new schism through the heart of Europe brings with it a familiar list of dangers and uncertainties”. The most pressing is that a Russian-held Ukraine will border a host of Nato member states, “raising the prospects of direct conflict”.

4. Escalation

That is the final potential outcome: an extension of the conflict into a war between Nato and Russia. This is described by the Atlantic Council as “the most dangerous scenario for the future of Europe and the global order”.

Western leaders have confirmed that they will not put boots on the ground in Ukraine or impose a Nato-enforced no-fly zone due to fears of direct engagement with Russia that could trigger a global conflict

But should Nato “decide to escalate its involvement in Ukraine”, the think tank warned, “Russia would be forced to decide whether to back down or directly engage alliance military forces”.

UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss has warned that if Russia is not stopped in Ukraine, “we are going to see others under threat – the Baltics, Poland, Moldova, and it could end up in a conflict with Nato”.

This would mean a conflict between atomic powers. And “it goes without saying”, said The Telegraph, “that any actual use of nuclear weapons would be disastrous beyond description”. 

Recommended

Why Ukraine is fighting to retake Snake Island
Snake Island
Getting to grips with . . .

Why Ukraine is fighting to retake Snake Island

‘Negotiation with Putin would be a moral disaster’
Vladimir Putin has previously deployed ‘extreme measures’ to crush opposition
Instant Opinion

‘Negotiation with Putin would be a moral disaster’

The countries that could follow Sri Lanka into chaos
Sri Lankans clash with police in Colombo amid the country’s economic crisis
Why we’re talking about . . .

The countries that could follow Sri Lanka into chaos

Is Bosnia on the brink of a civil war?
Bosnian Serb leader Milorad Dodik
In Depth

Is Bosnia on the brink of a civil war?

More on Ukraine

Why Ukraine is fighting to retake Snake Island
Snake Island
Getting to grips with . . .
27 May 2022

Why Ukraine is fighting to retake Snake Island

Tiny Black Sea outpost could hold key to avoiding global food shortage
The countries that could follow Sri Lanka into chaos
Sri Lankans clash with police in Colombo amid the country’s economic crisis
Why we’re talking about . . .
27 May 2022

The countries that could follow Sri Lanka into chaos

Food and fuel shortages that rocked Asian nation are spreading around the globe
Viktor Orbán’s state of emergency over Ukraine explained
Viktor Orbán addresses the Conservative Political Action Conference in Budapest, Hungary
Between the lines
26 May 2022

Viktor Orbán’s state of emergency over Ukraine explained

Hungary ends Covid crisis measures – and ushers in new ones over Russia’s invasion
What next for Russia’s high-profile defectors?
Vladimir Putin during a meeting of he Summit of Collective Security Treaty Organisation
In Depth
26 May 2022

What next for Russia’s high-profile defectors?

Only a few members of the business and political elite have criticised Ukraine war
The pros and cons of gene-editing food
A combine harvester works its way through a field of barley
Pros and cons
25 May 2022

The pros and cons of gene-editing food

Technique could increase food security but there are concerns about labelling
Can Ukraine beat Russia in Donbas?
Ukrainian troops on the frontline in Donbas
Getting to grips with . . .
25 May 2022

Can Ukraine beat Russia in Donbas?

‘Fate of the country’ could be decided by war in the eastern region, Kyiv says
Is Russian President Vladimir Putin seriously ill?
Vladimir Putin
Why we’re talking about . . .
24 May 2022

Is Russian President Vladimir Putin seriously ill?

Former MI6 chief suggests Russian leader may be forced into a sanatorium
Are assassins trying to kill Putin?
Vladimir Putin hosting a meeting in the Kremlin via video link
Behind the scenes
24 May 2022

Are assassins trying to kill Putin?

Ukraine’s head of intelligence claims Russian president has been target of hit
The religious leader providing ‘spiritual cover’ for Putin’s war
Patriarch Kirill I
Profile
23 May 2022

The religious leader providing ‘spiritual cover’ for Putin’s war

Patriarch Kirill I facing EU sanctions over support for Ukraine invasion
Will Russia’s ‘Terminator’ tanks break Ukraine’s resistance?
A BMPT ‘Terminator’ tank on display during last year’s Victory Day parade in Red Square
Today’s big question
20 May 2022

Will Russia’s ‘Terminator’ tanks break Ukraine’s resistance?

Moscow deploys armoured fighting vehicles in ‘sign of increasing frustration’
Will Ukraine invasion trigger a global food security crisis?
Harvest in Ukraine
In Focus
19 May 2022

Will Ukraine invasion trigger a global food security crisis?

Shortages of grain and fertiliser could last years, UN warns
The mystery of the sanction-busting plane
Grant Shapps
Why we’re talking about . . .
19 May 2022

The mystery of the sanction-busting plane

Jet left Scottish airport after flights were banned between UK and Russia
What will happen to Ukraine’s captured Mariupol troops?
More than 260 soldiers have so far been evacuated to Russian-controlled territory
The latest on . . .
18 May 2022

What will happen to Ukraine’s captured Mariupol troops?

Russian MPs call for fighters evacuated from Azovstal steelworks to be put to death
What are the phosphorus bombs ‘pummelling’ Ukraine?
White phosphorus being dropped by the Assad regime in Douma, Syria
Fact file
17 May 2022

What are the phosphorus bombs ‘pummelling’ Ukraine?

Footage shows ‘brightly burning munitions’ launched by Russian forces hitting Mariupol’s Azovstal steelworks
How much has the UK spent on Ukraine?
Boris Johnson and Volodymyr Zelenskyy
Today’s big question
17 May 2022

How much has the UK spent on Ukraine?

The government announced earlier this month it would send £1.3bn in military support to war-torn country
The fallout of Finland’s Nato membership bid
Finnish Prime Minister Sanna Marin addresses a press conference on Nato membership in April
Getting to grips with . . .
16 May 2022

The fallout of Finland’s Nato membership bid

Helsinki formally declares intention to join military alliance
Will Ukraine invasion usher in a new era of spying?
Ukrainian ground troops near the frontline in Kryvyi Rih
Unreported world
14 May 2022

Will Ukraine invasion usher in a new era of spying?

Moscow’s global intelligence network has been devastated by the ongoing conflict, experts claim
Nato vs. Russia: who would win?
Nato troops
In Depth
12 May 2022

Nato vs. Russia: who would win?

Finland announces intention to join military alliance
Why the Black Sea is key to Ukraine invasion
Aftermath of Russian bombing in Odesa
In Depth
12 May 2022

Why the Black Sea is key to Ukraine invasion

Moscow could threaten ‘millions with starvation’ through port blockade
The mysterious Russian oligarch deaths
Vladimir Putin has previously deployed ‘extreme measures’ to crush opposition
Why we’re talking about . . .
10 May 2022

The mysterious Russian oligarch deaths

Six figures with ties to the Kremlin have died since Vladimir Putin launched Ukraine war
Is Russia’s economy bouncing back?
Vladimir Putin and Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu attend the Victory Day parade in Red Square
The latest on . . .
9 May 2022

Is Russia’s economy bouncing back?

Moscow has been ‘surprisingly resilient’ so far, but disaster may be around the corner
Russian generals fear Putin ‘purge’
Vladimir Putin during meetings at the Kremlin
Behind the scenes
6 May 2022

Russian generals fear Putin ‘purge’

Moscow’s military top brass being blamed for Ukraine ‘quagmire’, defence minister says
What could UK army learn from Ukraine?
Defence Secretary Ben Wallace during a trip to Finland
Today’s big question
6 May 2022

What could UK army learn from Ukraine?

Kyiv troops’ experience of fighting Russia offers important lessons for UK, defence minister says
The breakaway republic in the Kremlin’s sights
Transnistria
Why we’re talking about . . .
5 May 2022

The breakaway republic in the Kremlin’s sights

Russian general says Moscow aims to create a ‘corridor’ across southern Ukraine to Transnistria
The Week Footer Banner