In Focus

Benefits vs. costs: is Universal Credit fit for purpose?

The system was designed to make claiming simpler - but critics say it creates ‘misery’

Boris Johnson has hinted that emergency universal credit payments may be extended beyond March in order to “make sure people don’t suffer” while Covid-19 lockdown measures remain in place.

As pressure grows on the government to extend the temporary £20-a-week payments, the prime minister told MPs yesterday that he will “look after people throughout the pandemic”.

Johnson made the pledge during a parliamentary debate ahead of a vote on a non-binding Labour motion calling for the top-up to be kept in place. The Tory leader told his MPs to abstain, but six Conservatives defied the order to side with the opposition in the vote, which passed with 278 in favour and none against.

Campaigners and charities say the £20 payment is a lifeline for the more than 5.5 million families who receive the standard universal credit allowance.

However, the system as a whole has been dogged by controversy since being introduced in 2013.

Universal credit was designed “to make claiming benefits simpler”, the BBC says. It replaced six benefits – including income support and housing benefit - and merged them into one payment.

Former Tory work and pensions minister Iain Duncan Smith, who devised the system, has insisted that “we will be grateful for universal credit” when looking back on the pandemic - and is calling on MPs “to stop trying to make it a political football”. 

In an article published on the i news site last month, he argues that under the “clunky” former system of benefit payments, “we would have had queues at Jobcentres snaking round city centres” as unemployment numbers rise.

Universal Credit supports people who have jobs too, Smith continues, including “those in work, in part-time work, in-between work and looking for work. The system will support them all.”

However, opposition to his brainchild remains strong both inside and outside of the Commons.

The New Statesman’s UK editor Anoosh Chakelian has argued that the way the scheme is “designed and automated” is “pushing people into poverty” and “creating misery” for claimants.

She highlights the method of means testing, which is based on the claimant’s past calendar month of earnings and is calculated by a “poorly designed” algorithm. “This means that irregular shifts, frequency and dates of payments, and fluctuations in a person’s earnings can be misinterpreted by the system - leaving some with very little income the following month because their earnings have been overestimated by the algorithm,” Chakelian writes.

The Spectator’s assistant editor Isabel Hardman is also highly critical of the system, arguing that its greatest flaw “is the shocking loss of money that some claimants face”.

Another major problem “is the amount of time it takes for claimants to receive it, which can leave many of them unable to cover their rent and so on”, she adds.

Recommended

‘How will we afford it?’
Today's newspaper front pages
Today’s newspapers

‘How will we afford it?’

Budget predictions: what’s Rishi Sunak got in store?
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak poses with the Budget Box outside 11 Downing Street
Today’s big question

Budget predictions: what’s Rishi Sunak got in store?

London ULEZ expansion: who is affected, plus charges, penalties and how to pay
ULEZ
In Depth

London ULEZ expansion: who is affected, plus charges, penalties and how to pay

MoD urged to investigate cover-up claims in murder of Kenyan woman
Defence Secretary Ben Wallace
Why we’re talking about . . .

MoD urged to investigate cover-up claims in murder of Kenyan woman

More on Universal Credit

‘Far from being a mere everyday annoyance, mansplaining can interfere with democracy’
Members of the Supreme Court pose for a group photo
Instant Opinion
19 Oct 2021

‘Far from being a mere everyday annoyance, mansplaining can interfere with democracy’

Your digest of analysis from the British and international press
Universal Credit cut: a guide to financial aid alternatives
Boris Johnson
In Depth
6 Oct 2021

Universal Credit cut: a guide to financial aid alternatives

Boris Johnson defends £20-a-week cut by arguing that taxpayers should not ‘subsidise’ low pay
‘If Boris Johnson felt shame, he wouldn’t be slashing universal credit’
Boris Johnson in New York City
Instant Opinion
24 Sep 2021

‘If Boris Johnson felt shame, he wouldn’t be slashing universal credit’

Your digest of analysis from the British and international press
The biggest problems facing Johnson as Parliament returns
Boris Johnson
Getting to grips with . . .
6 Sep 2021

The biggest problems facing Johnson as Parliament returns

Threat of backbench revolt looming over the PM following summer recess
DWP planning laws to spy on Universal Credit claimants’ bank accounts
Job Centre UK
In Brief
22 Oct 2020

DWP planning laws to spy on Universal Credit claimants’ bank accounts

Officials want access to the data for crackdown on fraudulent claims
Instant Opinion: the red wall ‘wants a U‑turn’ from Boris Johnson on universal credit
Boris Johnson leaves Downing Street flanked by Chancellor Rishi Sunak
In Depth
13 Oct 2020

Instant Opinion: the red wall ‘wants a U‑turn’ from Boris Johnson on universal credit

Your guide to the best columns and commentary on Tuesday 13 October
Quiz of The Week: 28 March - 3 April
police coronavirus
In Depth
3 Apr 2020

Quiz of The Week: 28 March - 3 April

Have you been paying attention to The Week’s news?
The great universal credit swindle
gettyimages-84736089.jpg
In Brief
9 Jul 2019

The great universal credit swindle

Multimillion-pound benefit scam is exposed as fraudsters target flagship scheme
Is the Government breaking human rights laws on child hunger?
Wandsworth food bank
In Brief
20 May 2019

Is the Government breaking human rights laws on child hunger?

Human Rights Watch report says Tory welfare cuts caused ‘hunger crisis’
Food bank use hits record high in Britain
Wandsworth food bank
In Brief
25 Apr 2019

Food bank use hits record high in Britain

Government benefit policies blamed as charity hands out 1.5m parcels in 12 months
Survival sex: inquiry launched as benefit claimants say they are forced into prostitution
Could prostitution soon be effectively decriminalised?
In Brief
19 Mar 2019

Survival sex: inquiry launched as benefit claimants say they are forced into prostitution

MPs to investigate whether universal credit failures means women have to sell their bodies
Why universal credit is like the Victorian workhouse
Hubert von Herkomer - Westminster Union
In Depth
16 Jan 2019

Why universal credit is like the Victorian workhouse

Policy coheres quite closely to that of amendments to the poor law in 1834, says history professor
Universal Credit roll-out delayed
wd-job_centre_-_matt_cardygetty_images.jpg
In Brief
7 Jan 2019

Universal Credit roll-out delayed

Vote to extend government’s flagship welfare programme to three million new claimants has been pushed back
Does universal credit discriminate against single parents?
wd-job_centre_-_matt_cardygetty_images.jpg
In Brief
28 Nov 2018

Does universal credit discriminate against single parents?

Four female plaintiffs launch legal challenge to government’s flagship welfare programme
What is universal credit?
UK currency
In Depth
16 Oct 2018

What is universal credit?

Government’s flagship welfare project aims to simplify benefits system but has been beset by controversy
Universal credit failings leave thousands in debt
A Job Centre in Bristol
In Brief
24 Jul 2018

Universal credit failings leave thousands in debt

‘Complex’ flagship welfare programme forcing people into rent arrears - and food banks
Esther McVey ‘misled’ MPs over universal credit
Work and Pensions Secretary Esther McVey leaves Downing Street
In Brief
5 Jul 2018

Esther McVey ‘misled’ MPs over universal credit

Work and Pensions secretary makes partial apology but also disputes some of the watchdog’s findings
Universal credit ‘may never deliver value for money’
People queuing outside a Job Centre in east London
In Depth
15 Jun 2018

Universal credit ‘may never deliver value for money’

Damning independent audit of welfare reform finds it is running behind schedule and not delivering on aims
Finland turns away from universal basic income
Finland has higher unemployment levels than other Scandinavian countries
In Brief
24 Apr 2018

Finland turns away from universal basic income

Government will not expand scheme that gives unconditional monthly payments instead of means-tested benefits
Government U-turn on axing housing benefit for 18- to 21-year-olds
Esther McVey
In Brief
29 Mar 2018

Government U-turn on axing housing benefit for 18- to 21-year-olds

Policy reversal follows outcry from homelessness charities
Children to ‘go hungry’ after free school meals cuts
Up to a million children could lose out under free school meal cuts
In Brief
14 Mar 2018

Children to ‘go hungry’ after free school meals cuts

Tories face backlash for exempting Northern Ireland from reforms which could affect one million children
Why are 300,000 jobless Britons not claiming benefits?
Hundreds of thousands of people are not claiming their benefits
In Brief
3 Jan 2018

Why are 300,000 jobless Britons not claiming benefits?

Resolution Foundation report urges Government to do more to help UK’s ‘forgotten unemployed’
One in five now live in poverty in the UK, report finds
Poverty
In Depth
4 Dec 2017

One in five now live in poverty in the UK, report finds

400,000 extra children and 300,000 extra pensioners among the poorest compared to 2013
Ten Things You Need to Know Today: Monday 29 Apr 2013
Daily Briefing
29 Apr 2013

Ten Things You Need to Know Today: Monday 29 Apr 2013

The Week Footer Banner