In Depth

Flood insurance: Government's leaky plan has Catch-22

Cost of the bad weather could reach £1bn, with claims expected to hit £30,000 each

WITH large parts of Britain still submerged and more rain forecast, albeit in smaller doses, in coming days there are fears that the nationwide clean-up operation will end up taking months rather than days or weeks.

So what does the future hold for the insurance industry and people living in areas at risk of flooding?

After the deluge, the bill

PwC has revised up its forecast for the cost of flooding in December and January to £630m, including a £500m bill for insurance, notes Hilary Osborne in The Guardian. But this could easily increase. "If the rains continue into March or April, it's not impossible for this to become a £1bn event," says Justin Gott of insurer Hiscox.

Household insurance claims in affected areas are expected to hit £30,000 to £40,000 each, according to Deloitte, and premiums may have to go up across the board to cover the cost. Meanwhile, there are growing concerns about the Government's very leaky new insurance plan for properties at risk.

Bad news for Old Rectories 

A 2000 agreement with the insurance industry gave most homeowners in flood hit areas access to "affordable" cover, says Rachel Rickard Strauss on Thisismoney.co.uk. Without it, hundreds of thousands of properties would have been effectively "worthless". But the agreement is set to expire and its replacement – a not-for-profit scheme called 'Flood Re' due to start in 2015 – has "new limitations". 

The proposals exclude new-build properties dating from 2009, and all leasehold and buy-to-let properties. Wealthy homeowners could also be whacked, says solicitor Victoria Davies of Harbottle & Lewis, The new deal only guarantees cover against damage to houses in council bands A to G, excluding the most valuable properties in band H. "This could make it hard for households in that band to get cover at all, or make it prohibitively expensive."

...and for leaseholders

To rub salt into the wound, these households will still "have to pay a levy" for Flood Re, says the Daily Telegraph: owners of all of high-risk properties must cough up a £540 premium to fund the scheme – even if they don't qualify for its protection. No wonder even some insurers dismiss it as "unworkable".

Arguably worse off, are some 50,000 leaseholders in affected areas, says Alistair Gray in the FT. To be eligible for Flood Re, the property must "be occupied by the policyholder"; but leaseholders "are prevented from buying buildings insurance under the terms of their lease".  Talk about a Catch-22. 

A version of this article appears in the 15 February 2014 edition of The Week

Recommended

Headers, savings and costly chips
Jordan Henderson heads the ball
Podcasts

Headers, savings and costly chips

Who is eligible for the cost-of-living payment?
Cost of living
The latest on . . .

Who is eligible for the cost-of-living payment?

Eight solutions for your finances, investment and retirement planning
An older woman sat at a laptop with a younger woman hugging her from behind
Advertisement Feature

Eight solutions for your finances, investment and retirement planning

When will paper £20 and £50 notes expire?
Paper banknotes
Business Briefing

When will paper £20 and £50 notes expire?

Popular articles

Will China invade Taiwan?
Chinese troops on mobile rocket launchers during a parade in Beijing
Fact file

Will China invade Taiwan?

Is World War Three on the cards?
Ukrainian soldiers patrol on the frontline in Zolote, Ukraine
In Depth

Is World War Three on the cards?

Best new TV crime dramas of 2022
Roger Allam and Nancy Carroll in Murder in Provence
In Depth

Best new TV crime dramas of 2022

The Week Footer Banner